Sequence composition effects on the stabilities of triple helix formation by
oligonucleotides containing
N
7
-deoxyguanosine
Sequence composition effects on the stabilities of triple helix formation by oligonucleotides containing N 7 -deoxyguanosine
Helmut
Brunar
and
Peter B.
Dervan*
Division of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, California Institute of
Technology,
Pasadena
, CA 91125,
USA
Received March 25, 1996;
Accepted April 13, 1996
ABSTRACT
A nonnatural nucleoside, 7-(2-deoxy-
[beta]
-D-
erythro
-pento-furanosyl)-guanine (d
7
G), mimics protonated cytosine and specifically binds GC base pairs within a
pyrimidine
@
purine
@
pyrimidine triple helix.
The differences in association constants (K
T
) determined by quantitative footprint titration experiments at neutral pH
reveal dramatic sequence composition effects on the energetics of triple helix
formation by oligonucleotides containing d
7
G.
Purine tracts of sequence composition 5
'
-d(AAAAAGAGAGAGAGA)-3
'
are bound by oligonucleotide 5
'
-d(TTTTT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT)-3
'
three orders of magnitude less strongly than by 5
'
-d(TTTTT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT)-3
'
(K
T
= 1.5*10
6
M
-1
and K
T
>=
3*10
9
M
-1
respectively).
Conversely, purine tracts of sequence composition 5
'
-d(AAAAGAAAAGGGGGGA)-3
'
are bound by oligonucleotide 5
'
-d(TTTT
m
CTTTT
7
G
7
G
7
G
7
G
7
G
7
GT)-3
'
five orders of magnitude more strongly than by 5
'
-d(TTTT
m
CTTTT
m
C
m
C
m
C
m
C
m
CT)-3
'
(K
T
>=
3*10
9
M
-1
and K
T
< 5*10
4
M
-1
respectively).
The complementary nature of d
7
G and
m
C expands the repertoire of G-rich sequences which may be targeted by triple helix formation.
INTRODUCTION
The thermodynamic stability of pyrimidine@purine@pyrimidine triple helices decreases with increasing pH due to the requirement
of protonating cytosine bases to form C+GC triplets (
1
-
4
). Within the context of pyrimidine oligonucleotide-directed recognition of double helical DNA, there are serious sequence composition limitations
with regard to targeting contiguous G-rich purine tracts near physiological pH, presumably due to electrostatic
repulsion between protonated cytosines in adjacent C+GC triplets. Replacement
of cytosine by 5-methylcytosine (
m
C) increases the stability of pyrimidine@purine@pyrimidine triple helices, but does not alleviate the pH dependence (
2
-
5
). Development of oligonucleotides whose energetics of triple helix formation
are less sensitive to pH would benefit applications which require near
physiologically relevant conditions.
In an attempt to eliminate the necessity for protonation, recent efforts have
been directed toward the synthesis of nonnatural nucleosides which display the
hydrogen bonding functionality of protonated cytosine (
6
-
17
). We previously reported that an
N
7
-glycosylated purine, 7-(2-deoxy-[beta]-D-
erythro
-pentofuranosyl) guanine (d
7
G), when incorporated in a single position within a pyrimidine oligonucleotide,
binds with remarkable specificity the Watson-Crick guanine-cytosine (GC) base pair by triple helix formation (
16
). By attaching the deoxyribose moiety at the N
7
-position of a guanine base, the third strand orientation in a G@GC base triplet is reversed and becomes parallel to the purine Watson-Crick strand (Fig.
1
) (
16
).
Although NMR studies do not reveal any major backbone distortion for
7
G@GC triplets, the
7
G@GC triplet is not isomorphous with adjacent T@AT triplets (
18
). Envisioning a new parallel-stranded motif comprising wholly
N
7
purines for DNA recognition by triple helix formation, we were interested
whether triple helices containing multiple d
7
G residues are energetically disfavoured relative to
m
C at neutral pH.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
RESULTS
Sequence composition effects on the energetics of triple helix formation by
oligonucleotides containing multiple d
7
G moieties were examined for two different purine target sites within 242 and
253 bp restriction fragments at pH 7.0 and 7.5. The sequence of one site is the
purine tract 5'-d(AAAAAGAGAGAGAGA)-3' in a 242 bp restriction fragment [referred to as the
(GA)
5
site] (Fig.
3
A). The other purine site is derived from the LTR region of the HIV genome and
has the sequence 5'-d(AAAAGAAAAGGGGGGA)-3' in a 253 bp restriction fragment (referred to as the
G
6
site) (Fig.
3
B).
The energetics of association of oligonucleotides
1
and
2
of sequence composition 5'-d(TTTTT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT
m
CT)-3' and 5'-d(TTTTT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT
7
GT)-3' respectively, allow comparison of the ability of
m
C and d
7
G to bind multiple GC base pairs in a target sequence composed of alternating G
and A nucleotides [the (GA)
5
site] (Table
1
). Similarly, the energetics of binding oligonucleotides
3
and
4
of sequence composition 5'-d(TTTT
m
CTTTT
m
C
m
C
m
C
m
C
m
C
m
CT)-3' and 5'-d(TTTT
m
CTTTT
7
G
7
G
7
G
7
G
7
G
7-
GT)-3' allow this comparison for a target sequence containing contiguous
GC base pairs (the G
6
site) (Table
2
).
.
Equilibrium association constants for triple helix formation at the (GA)
5
site
a
Oligo
pH
K
T
(M
-1
)
1
7.0
>=
3
*
10
9
7.5
9.4 * 10
7
2
7.0
1.5 * 10
6
7.5
1.1 * 10
6
a
Each reported K
T
value is the mean of three independent measurements which were performed in 100
mM NaCl, 10 mM bis Tris-HCl, 250 [mu]M spermine at the indicated pH and 22oC.
.
Equilibrium association constants for triple helix formation at the G
6
site
a
Oligo
pH
K
T
(M
-1
)
3
7.0
<5 * 10
4
7.5
<10
4
4
7.0
>=
3
*
10
9
7.5
>= 2 * 10
9
a
Each reported K
T
value is the mean of three independent measurements which were performed in 100
mM NaCl, 10 mM bis Tris-HCl, 250 [mu]M spermine at the indicated pH and 22oC.
Figure 6
.
([theta]
app
, [O]
tot
) data derived from the DNase footprinting gels shown in Figures 4 and 5 for
binding of oligonucleotide
2
(o) and
4
(n) to the (GA)
5
and G
6
target sites respectively.
Consistent with previous data which has shown that triple helix formation by
oligonucleotides containing cytosine or
m
C is pH-dependent (
2
-
5
,
17
), we have reported recently that oligonucleotide
1
, containing
m
C and T, binds tightly to the (GA)
5
site (K
T
>= 3 * 10
9
M
-1
) at pH 7.0, and that this affinity drops by a factor of >= 30 as the pH is increased to 7.5 (
17
). At pH 7.0, oligonucleotide
2
, containing d
7
G in place of
m
C, binds three orders of magnitude weaker than oligonucleotide
1
, albeit pH independently over the range studied (Figs
4
and
6
). The relative affinities are reversed for the G
6
target sequence containing contiguous GC base pairs. Oligonucleotide
3
, which contains (
m
C)
6
, binds the G
6
site very weakly (K
T
< 5 * 10
4
M
-1
)
at pH 7.0. In the case of oligonucleotide
4
, which contains (d
7
G)
6
, the association constant at pH 7.0 is very high (K
T
>= 3 * 10
9
M
-1
) (Figs
5
and
6
). Notably, the high affinity of oligonucleotide
4
decreases by a factor of <2 at pH 7.5.
DISCUSSION
The (GA)
5
site contains ten 5'-AG-3' or 5'-GA-3' junctions, while the G
6
site contains only two such junctions in the region of interest. The three
orders of magnitude difference in the affinity of d
7
G containing oligonucleotides for these two sites is probably due to the lack of
structural isomorphism in the
7
G@GC and T@AT triplets. The location of the third strand deoxyribose-phosphate backbone is not identical when the two triplets are overlaid.
Thus, the 5'-AG-3' and 5'-GA-3' junctions could generate
energetically unfavourable distortions in the backbone in triple helical complexes relative to contiguous A or G sequences. In the case of
m
C containing oligonucleotides the large difference in affinity for the two sites
is probably due to electrostatic repulsion between adjacent protonated
m
C bases (
17
).
A quantitative study of the energetics of triple helix formation for different
purine tracts has revealed that
m
C and d
7
G provide complementary solutions to the recognition of GC base pairs by triple
helix formation. At neutral pH,
m
C binds isolated GC base pairs with higher affinity than d
7
G, while d
7
G binds contiguous GC base pairs with higher affinity than
m
C. Remarkably, both types of G-rich tracts can be targeted by choice of the appropriate oligonucleotide
composition.
In conclusion, we found that within the measured pH range the stabilities of d
7
G containing triple helical structures were strongly dependent on the sequence
context and independent from the pH. A third strand oligonucleotide composed of
contiguous d
7
G nucleosides provides a conveniently accessible solution for targeting
contiguous guanosine and hence broadens the sequence repertoire available by
oligonucleotide directed triple helix formation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to the Office of Naval Research for support and to the Austrian
Science Foundation for an Erwin Schrödinger Postdoctoral Fellowship to H.B.
13 Davison, E.C. and Johnsson, K. (1993) Nucleosides Nucleotides, 12, 237-243.
14 Xiang, G., Soussou, W. and McLaughlin, L.W. (1994) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 116, 11155-11156.
15 von Krosigk, U. and Benner, S.A. (1995) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 117, 5361-5362.
16 Hunziker, J., Priestley, E.S., Brunar, H. and Dervan, P.B. (1995) J. Am. Chem. Soc.117, 2661-2662.
17 Priestley, E.S. and Dervan, P.B. (1995) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117, 4761-4765.
18 Koshlap, K.M., Wang, E., Brunar, H., Gillespie, P., Dervan, P.B. and Feigon, J. (1995) J. Biomolec. Struct. Dyn.12, a111.
19 Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E.F. and Maniatis, T. (1989) Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual 2nd Edition. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY.
20 Rao, T.S., Durland, R.H. and Revankar, G.R. (1994) J. Heterocyclic Chem., 31, 935-940.
21 Blair, M.G., Lipkin, D., Sowden, J.C. and Strobach, J.C. (1960) J. Org. Chem., 25, 1679-1680.
22 Hrebabecky, H. and Farkas, J. (1978) In Townsend, L.B. and Tipson, R.S. (eds), Nucleic Acid Chemistry. J. Wiley & Sons, NY, Vol. 1.
23 Brenowitz, M., Senear, D.F., Shea, M.A. and Ackers, G.K. (1986) Methods Enzymol., 130, 132-181.MEDLINE Abstract
24 Singleton, S.F. and Dervan, P.B. (1992) J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114, 6957-6965.