ABSTRACT
Ubiquitin conjugating enzymes (UBCs) are a family of proteins directly involved
in ubiquitination of proteins. Ubiquitination is known to be involved in
control of a variety of cellular processes, including cell proliferation,
through the targeting of key regulatory proteins for degradation. The
ubc9
gene of the yeast
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
(Sc
ubc9
) is an essential gene which is required for cell cycle progression and is
involved in the degradation of S phase and M phase cyclins. We have identified
a human homolog of Sc
ubc9
(termed h
ubc9
) using the two hybrid screen for proteins that interact with the human
papillomavirus type 16 E1 replication protein. The h
ubc9
encoded protein shares a very high degree of amino acid sequence similarity
with ScUBC9 and with the homologous
hus5
+ gene product of
Schizosaccharomyces pombe
. Genetic complementation experiments in a
S.cerevisiae
ubc9ts
mutant reveal that hUBC9 can substitute for the function of ScUBC9 required for
cell cycle progression.
The ubiquitin-dependent proteolytic system is a major pathway for the selective
degradation of proteins in eukaryotes. This proteolytic system plays an
important role in controlling the levels of key enzymes and regulatory proteins
and in preventing the accumulation of abnormal proteins in cells (
1
-
4
). Ubiquitination of proteins is accomplished by an ATP-dependent multi-step pathway that is initiated by the activation of ubiquitin by
ubiquitin activating enzymes, following by substrate-specific conjugation by ubiquitin conjugating enzymes (UBCs) and ubiquitin-protein ligases (
1
-
4
). The UBCs participate in the transfer of ubiquitin to a target protein either
directly or through the participation of a ubiquitin-protein ligase, such as Ubr1 (
5
), E3[alpha] (
2
), E3[beta] (
2
) and E6-AP (
6
). The covalent linkage of ubiquitin to substrate proteins serves to signal
their degradation by the 26S proteasome (
7
).
Members of the UBC proteins contain a highly conserved catalytic site. Previous
studies in
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
have identified at least 10 different UBCs that are involved in various
cellular processes, such as DNA repair, sporulation, cell cycle progression,
heat shock resistance and peroxisome biogenesis (
1
-
3
). Among these
S.cerevisiae
UBCs, the yeast enzymes UBC3/CDC34 and UBC9 are the only ones that have been
shown individually to be essential for cell viability (
3
). Repression of ScUBC9 synthesis prevents cell cycle progression at the G2 or
early M phase, causing the accumulation of large budded cells with a single
nucleus, a short spindle and replicated DNA (
8
). Furthermore, the accumulation of both CLB5, an S phase cyclin and CLB2, an M
phase cyclin, has been observed in mutants of ScUBC9 (
8
). The
Schizosaccharomyces pombe
hus5
+
gene product, a structural homolog of ScUBC9, is also required for normal
mitosis (
9
).
We have now isolated and characterized a human UBC, termed hUBC9, because of the
high degree of similarity of the predicted amino acid sequence to ScUBC9. The h
ubc9
gene encodes a transcript of 1.3 kb and the h
ubc9
open reading frame encodes a protein of 158 amino acids with a predicted
molecular size of 18 kDa. The expression of hUBC9 protein can support the
growth of
ubc9
temperature sensitive mutants at non-permissive temperatures, indicating that hUBC9 is a functional homolog of
ScUBC9.
A yeast two hybrid screen was performed according to previously developed
systems (
10
-
12
) as modified by Dr Marc Vidal (
13
). The bait plasmid was constructed by inserting the full-length
E1
gene of human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV16) in-frame with the GAL4 DNA binding domain (amino acids 1-147) in the pPC97 vector (pPC97-16E1). The pPC97 and pPC86 vectors, an activated human T cell
cDNA library cloned in the pPC86 vector and the yeast host strain MaV103 (MAT
a
ura3-52 leu2-3,112 trp1-901 his3
[Delta]
200 ade2-101 gal4
[Delta]
gal80
[Delta]
GAL1
::
LacZ GAL1
::
HIS3@lys2 SPAL10
::
URA3
) were kindly provided by Drs Marc Vidal and Joshua La Baer (Massachusetts
General Hospital, Charlestown, MA) (
13
). Selection was based on the presence of the
HIS3
gene cloned downstream of GAL4 DNA binding sites. Increased
HIS3
expression results as a consequence of an interacting clone. Since
HIS3
expression renders yeast resistant to 3-aminotriazole (3AT), different concentrations of 3AT can be used to select
interacting clones. The selection of interaction-positive clones was performed on plates containing 75 mM 3AT to reduce the
background growth of the yeast transformants harboring pPC97-16E1. pPC86-derived prey plasmids containing cDNA were rescued from positive
clones by transformation of competent DH5[alpha] bacteria with total yeast DNA. The sequence of both strands of the h
ubc9
cDNA insert was determined with appropriate synthetic oligonucleotide primers
by dideoxynucleotide sequencing using Sequenase 2.0 (United States
Biochemical).
The Sc
ubc9
gene was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using appropriate
synthetic oligonucleotides and cloned into yeast centromeric plasmid pRS316
(Stratagene), yielding pRS316-ScUBC9. The pRS316 vector contains the
URA3
selectable marker. The yeast expression plasmid pTY316 was constructed by
inserting a pPC86-derived
Kpn
I-
Hin
dIII fragment of the highly expressed
S.cerevisiae
ADC1
promoter into the pRS316 vector (Stratagene). A
Not
I restriction fragment of the pPC86 library plasmid containing h
ubc9
cDNA was subcloned downstream of the
ADC1
promoter in pTY316 (pTY316-hUBC9wt). The substitution mutant of h
ubc9
(Cys -> Ser at codon 93, TGC -> AGC) was generated using PCR-mediated, site-directed mutagenesis (
14
). This h
ubc9
mutant (h
ubc9mt
) was also cloned downstream of the
ADC1
promoter in pTY316 (pTY316-hUBC9mt). To obtain yeast expression plasmids for epitope-tagged hUBC9wt and hUBC9mt, fragments containing the full coding
region of h
ubc9
cDNA along with the influenza virus hemagglutinin 1 epitope (HA) sequence
(YPYDVPDYA) at the 3'-end were produced with appropriate synthetic oligonucleotides using
PCR. These fragments were cloned into the pCMV
4
vector (
15
) at a
Bgl
II site, yielding pCMV-hUBC9wtHA and pCMV-hUBC9mtHA. The
Eco
RI restriction fragments from these pCMV
4
-derived plasmids, containing HA-tagged h
ubc9
cDNA and the human growth hormone terminator sequence, were cloned downstream
of the
ADC1
promoter in pTY316, yielding plasmids pTY316-hUBC9wtHA and pTY316-hUBC9mtHA.
The
S.cerevisiae
UBC9 temperature sensitive mutant (
ubc9ts
) strain YWO102 (MAT[alpha],
ubc9-
[Delta]
1
::
TRP1
,
LEU2
::
ubc9-1
) (
9
) was kindly provided by Dr Stefan Jentsch. The
S.cerevisiae
UBC3/CDC34 temperature sensitive mutant (
ubc3ts
) strain KY203 (MAT
a
,
ura3-52
,
leu2-
[Delta]
2
,
bas1-2
,
bas2-2
,
gcn4-
[Delta]
1
, [alpha][delta][epsilon]
8-GCN4
,
cdc34-2
) (
16
) was kindly provided by Dr Daniel Kornitzer. Standard genetic techniques for
S.cerevisiae
were used (
17
).
The
Not
I restriction fragment of cDNA including the protein coding sequence plus the 3'-UTR of h
ubc9
and the human [beta]-actin cDNA fragment were radiolabeled with [[alpha]-
32
P]dCTP. The radiolabeled probes were hybridized to a multi-tissue Northern (MTN) blot (Clontech). The blot was hybridized at 60oC and washed at 65oC in 0.1* SSC, 0.1% SDS according to the manufacturer's
instructions. The blot was then exposed to X-ray film overnight with double intensity screens at -70oC.
In studies designed to examine the functions of HPV16 E1, a protein essential
for the initiation of viral DNA replication, we used the yeast two hybrid
system to identify cDNA clones that encode proteins that can interact with the
HPV16 E1 protein. The prey library was introduced into the yeast reporter
strain MaV103 containing pPC97-16E1. Approximately 1.0 * 10
7
primary library transformants were plated out onto histidine dropout plates
containing 75 mM 3AT. Five independent clones containing an identical ~1300 bp cDNA were found among a total of 16 positive clones from this two
hybrid screen.
The tissue distribution of h
ubc9
expression was determined by Northern blot analysis using h
ubc9
cDNA as a probe to hybridize polyadenylated RNAs (~2 [mu]g/lane; Clonetech) derived from a variety of human tissues. As shown in
Figure
3
the h
ubc9
probe detected a transcript of 1.3 kb in each of the human tissues examined,
indicating that h
ubc9
is ubiquitously expressed. Expression of this 1.3 kb polyadenylated RNA was
also detected in the immortalized human keratinocyte cell line HaCaT (data not
shown).
The high degree of amino acid identity between hUBC9 and ScUBC9 suggested that
the human gene might function similarly to Sc
ubc9
. To examine this possibility, the h
ubc9
gene was tested for its ability to complement the cell cycle progression
defects of a
ubc9
temperature sensitive (ts) mutant in
S.cerevisiae
. Cells harboring the
ubc9ts
mutation grow normally at 25oC and fail to grow at the non-permissive temperature, >35oC (
8
). For these experiments, epitope-tagged versions of the wild-type h
ubc9
gene, as well as a mutant h
ubc9
gene in which codon 93 was changed to encode serine instead of cysteine were
cloned into a yeast expression plasmid. These plasmids, designated pTY316-hUBC9wtHA and pTY316-hUBC9mtHA, were introduced into the
S.cerevisiae
ubc9ts
mutant strain YWO102 by transformation. Plasmids pRS316-ScUBC9 and pTY316 were also introduced into YWO102 as positive and
negative controls, respectively. Each of the transformants was streaked on
plates containing selective minimal glucose medium and their growth was
assessed at 25 and 37oC. Growth of YWO102 transformants was observed at 37oC for the transformants containing the positive control pRS316-ScUBC9, for transformants containing pTY316-hUBC9wtHA (Fig.
4
upper), as well as for transformants harboring the plasmid pTY316-hUBC9wt expressing a non-tagged version of the h
ubc9
gene (data not shown). No growth was observed at 37oC for transformants harboring pTY316-hUBC9mt (data not shown) or transformants harboring the plasmid
pTY316-hUBC9mtHA (Fig.
4
upper). These results indicate that hUBC9 can complement the function of ScUBC9
and that the HA epitope tagged to the C-terminus does not affect hUBC9 function. The expression of hUBCBC9mt
(C93S) could not complement the function of ScUBC9, indicating that the
conserved cysteine of hUBC9 at codon 93 is required for the function of hUBC9
as a ubiquitin conjugating enzyme. Equivalent expression of both HA-tagged wild-type hUBC9 and the C93S mutant hUBC9 in YWO102 was documented by
Western blot analysis using a HA-specific monoclonal antibody 12CA5 (Fig.
5
).
Here, we report the cDNA cloning and characterization of a human ubiquitin
conjugating enzyme, hUBC9, that is a structural and functional homolog of
ScUBC9. The high degree of structural and functional conservation between hUBC9
and ScUBC9 implies that both human and yeast proteins may interact with
specific cellular factors that are also well conserved between human and yeast.
Overall there is >50% amino acid identity between hUBC9 and ScUBC9. There are
two regions that are particularly well conserved, one flanking Cys93 and the
other consisting of amino acids Arg8-Phe24. The region flanking Cys93 is conserved among the various human
UBCs, suggesting that this region may be involved in interactions with
ubiquitin activating enzyme, because the cysteine residue conserved among the
UBCs participates in the thioester linkage with ubiquitin, which is transferred
directly to UBCs from the ubiquitin activating enzyme. The other conserved
region, including amino acids Arg8-Phe24, might be involved in interactions with a specific ubiquitin-protein ligase or directly with the specific cellular targets,
because the high degree of conservation of amino acids in this region does not
extend to other human UBCs (Fig.
2
A). There are several studies that suggest the functional importance of
S.cerevisiae
UBCs N-terminal amino acid sequences. In the case of UBC8, the first 12 amino
acids of the N-terminus are important for ubiquitination of histones
in vitro
(
23
). Watkins
et al
. have reported that the first nine amino acids of RAD6 (UBC2) are required for
its physical interaction with yeast Ubr1 and that deletion of this region
affects RAD6 function in sporulation and DNA repair (
25
). Mutational analysis of UBC9 will be required to clarify the role of these
conserved domains.
Loss of ScUBC9 function in yeast cells results in the accumulation of the B-type cyclins CLB5 and CLB2 (
8
). The ability of hUBC9 to drive cell cycle progression in
S.cerevisiae
with a
ubc9ts
mutation raises the intriguing possibility that hUBC9 may also be involved in
the ubiquitination of specific cyclins and play an important role in cell cycle
progression in human cells. Identification of the specific cellular targets of
hUBC9 may help to elucidate its exact role in cell cycle progression.
Although h
ubc9
cDNA was identified through a two hybrid screen using HPV16 E1 protein, the
significance of the interaction between HPV16 E1 and hUBC9 has not yet been
determined. The E1 proteins of the papillomaviruses are essential for the
initiation of viral DNA replication and have been shown to have ATP binding,
ATPase and helicase activities (
15
,
26
). The levels of the E1 protein are believed to be quite low in infected cells
and it is not known whether E1 levels are regulated in a cell cycle-dependent manner. Nonetheless, the interaction of hUBC9 and HPV16 E1 in
yeast raises the possibility that E1 may be a target of the ubiquitin-dependent proteolytic pathway and that the E1 protein levels in HPV-infected cells might be regulated by a pathway governed by hUBC9.
Alternatively, E1 might somehow modulate the activity of hUBC9 for the benefit
of efficient viral DNA replication and might therefore influence cell cycle
progression of mammalian cells. These hypotheses will be tested by further
experiments trying to determine the physiological significance of the E1-hUBC9 interaction.
We thank Drs Marc Vidal and Joshua La Baer for the vectors, the yeast strain of
the two-hybrid system and the human T cell library. We also thank Drs Stefan
Jentsch and Daniel Kornitzer for providing yeast strains. We are grateful to
Charles Ro for DNA sequencing and to Drs John D.Benson, Sushant Kumar and
Hiroyuki Sakai for helpful discussions and comments on the manuscript. This
work was supported in part by a Sponsored Research Agreement to Harvard
University from the Terumo Corporation of Japan.
Chevray,P.M. and Nathans,D. (1992)
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
,
89
, 5789-5793.
REFERENCES
Return



