Skip Navigation

This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Print PDF (247K) Freely available
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to My Personal Archive
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowRequest Permissions
Right arrow Commercial Re-use Guidelines
for Open Access NAR Content
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Lelandais, C
Right arrow Articles by Chetrit, P
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Lelandais, C
Right arrow Articles by Chetrit, P
Social Bookmarking
 Add to CiteULike   Add to Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us  
What's this?

© 1995 Oxford University Press 4798-4804

Footnote

A promoter element active in run-off transcription controls the expression of two cistrons of nad and rps genes in Nicotiana sylvestris mitochondria

A promoter element active in run-off transcription controls the expression of two cistrons of nad and rps genes in Nicotiana sylvestris mitochondria Christine Lelandais* , Sophie Gutierres , Chantal Mathieu , Fernand Vedel , Claire Remacle 1 , Laurence Maréchal-Drouard 1 , Axel Brennicke 2 , Stefan Binder 2 and Philippe Chétrit

Institut de Biotechnologie des Plantes, URA 1128, Bâtiment 630, Université Paris-Sud, F- 91405 Orsay cedex, France , 1 Institut de Biologie Moléculaire des Plantes, 12 rue du Général Zimmer, F- 67084 Strasbourg , France and 2 Allgemeine Botanik, Universität Ulm, Albert Einstein Allee, D-89069 Ulm , Germany

Received July 16, 1996 ; Revised and Accepted October 23, 1996

ABSTRACT

The expression of two mitochondrial gene clusters ( orf87-nad3-nad1/A and orf87-nad3-rps12 ) was studied in Nicotiana sylvestris . 5 ' and 3 ' termini of transcripts were mapped by primer extension and nuclease S1 protection. Processing and transcription initiation sites were differentiated by in vitro phosphorylation and capping experiments. A transcription initiation site, present in both gene clusters, was found 213 nucleotides upstream of orf87 . This promoter element matches the consensus motif for dicotyledonous mitochondrial promoters and initiates run-off transcription in a pea mitochondrial purified protein fraction. Processing sites were identified 5 ' of nad3 , nad1/A and rps12 respectively. These results suggest that (i) the expression of the two cistrons is only controlled by one duplicated promoter element, and (ii) multiple processing events are required to produce monocistronic nad3 , nad1/A and rps12 transcripts.

INTRODUCTION

In comparison with mammals and fungi, the expression of mitochondrial (mt) genes in plants and especially the regulatory role of promoter regions is still poorly documented. In mammals, the mt genome is small as compared with higher plants (16 versus 200-2000 kb). Transcription is initiated from two promoters located in the non coding D-loop region and produces essentially two polycistronic primary transcripts, each corresponding to one strand of the circular genome ( 1 ). In yeast, several polycistronic transcripts have been characterized and the 20 identified transcription initiation sites share a nonanucleotide consensus element having the capability to initiate in vitro transcription ( 2 ). In higher plants, mt genes are dispersed throughout the genome and are often separated by large non coding regions. In contrast with the coding sequences, gene flanking regions are poorly conserved ( 3 ), making each investigation on gene expression a particular case. Another peculiarity is the presence , for some genes, of multiple transcription initiation and/or processing and termination sites frequently resulting in complex transcription patterns ( 4 , 5 ). Nevertheless, the recent development of in vitro transcription systems for plant mitochondria has allowed rapid progress for the understanding of promoter structures. In the maize atp1 gene, an 11 nucleotide (nt) promoter consensus was identified by deletion experiments ( 6 ). Linker scanning and site-directed mutagenesis further established the fundamental role of a 12 nt central domain surrounding the initiation site ( 7 ). In dicots, a consensus sequence of 29 nt with a highly conserved core of 9 nt was reported in Oenothera berteriana ( 8 , 9 ). A 20-30 nt more precise consensus sequence was defined by in vitro transcription at the initiation sites of several mt dicotyledonous genes coding for mRNAs and tRNAs ( 10 ). From these studies, only a short motif of 4 nt (CRTA) appears to be common to the mono- and dicotyledonous mt promoter sequences ( 3 ). Characterization of transcription initiation sites in additional genes of different species will be useful to describe more accurately the nature of plant mt promoters.

Although many plant mt genes are expressed independently, some coding sequences are co-transcribed in the form of long multicistronic primary transcripts. Some gene clusters, such as rrn18 - rrn5 , nad3-rps12 or rps3-rpl16 , have been found in virtually all species investigated so far ( 11 ). However most of the gene clusters appear to be specific of one or a few species, as for example atp9 - rps13 in tobacco ( 12 ), coxIII - orf25 ( 13 ) and the rps3-rpl16-nad3-rps12 units in rice ( 14 ). Northern and RT-PCR experiments confirmed co-transcription of the associated genes, but many questions are still to be addressed in concern of the expression and functional significance of the gene clusters.

In the solanaceous species Nicotiana sylvestris, an orf called orf87 and the nad3 gene are present in two mt genomic regions. In the first, they are located upstream of rps12 while in the second, the exon A of nad1 (named nad1/A ) has been identified downstream of nad3 ( 15 ). Previous RT-PCR experiments showed that the coding sequences in the two different gene clusters are co-transcribed ( 15 ). In this study, transcription of both genomic regions in N.sylvestris mitochondria was investigated by mapping transcription initiation, processing and termination sites.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Plant material

The fertile N.sylvestris line (T) is a botanical wild-type line provided by the Institut des Tabacs (SEITA, Bergerac, France) and has been maintained by self pollination for >15 generations. Plants were grown in greenhouses under 16 h day length at 24oC (day) and 17oC (night). Pea seedlings ( Pisum sativum L., var. Progress No.9 and var. Lancet) used in run-off transcription assays were grown in the dark for 7 days before extraction of mitochondria.

Nicotiana sylvestris recombinant plasmids

Plasmid clones KS5.3 and KS7 contain the 5.3 and 7 kb Sac I restriction fragments of N.sylvestris mt DNA, that are respectively carrying the orf87-nad3-nad1/A and orf87-nad3-rps12 cistrons ( 15 ). Sequences corresponding to both loci are available in the DDBJ/EMBLGenBank library under accession numbers X96741 and X96742. Clones 1-3 (Figs 3 A and 4 A) were obtained by subcloning three PCR-products into the vector pUC18 according to the `SureClone ligation kit' protocol (Pharmacia) and were maintained in the Escherichia coli DH5[alpha] host strain. These PCR products, amplified using KS5.3 as template, were respectively a 1.2 kb fragment, spanning the orf87 upstream region (primers O2 and O6, see primers section), a 729 bp fragment corresponding to the orf87-nad3 intergenic region (primers O7 and O8) and a 230 bp fragment, spanning the nad3 - nad1/A intergenic region (primers O4 and O9). PCR experiments were performed in a final volume of 25 [mu]l: 20-50 ng of DNA template were mixed with 50 pmol of each primer, 0.2 mM of each dNTP, 1 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Appligene) and 2.5 [mu]l of the 10* Taq polymerase buffer supplied by the manufacturer. Each of the 30 cycles consisted of 1 min at 92oC, 2 min at the primer annealing temperature and 1 min at 72oC.

Clone 4 (Figs 3 A and 4 A) and clone 5 (Fig. 5 ) contain the nad3-rps12 intergenic region and part of the rps12 coding sequence, and correspond to the 115 bp Spe I- Xho I and to the 370 bp Spe I- Eco RI subfragments of KS7 respectively. These restriction fragments were subcloned into the vectors pBluescript KS+ or SK+ (Stratagene) following standard procedures ( 16 ).

Mitochondrial RNA extraction

Nicotiana sylvestris mt were isolated from young leaves by differential centrifugation and were purified on discontinuous sucrose gradient, as described elsewhere ( 17 ). Mitochondria were lysed in 10 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5, 10 mM MgCl 2 , 1% (w/v) SDS, followed by extraction with 1 vol of water-saturated phenol. Large mt RNAs were isolated by LiCl precipitation ( 18 ).

Nucleic acid analysis

DNA sequencing was performed using the T7 sequencing kit (Pharmacia). DNAs were fractionated in 0.8% non denaturing agarose gels, and were transferred on Hybond N membrane according to the manufacturer's instructions (Amersham).

Primer extension

5'-end-labelling of primers (10 pmol) was performed using 10 U of T4 polynucleotide kinase (Gibco-BRL) and 5 [mu]l of [[gamma]- 32 P]ATP (3000 Ci/mmol) according to ( 16 ).

100 000 c.p.m. of each labelled primer were co-precipitated with 50 [mu]g of N.sylvestris total mt RNAs in ethanol for 20 min at -80oC. After a 20 min centrifugation at 15 000 g , the pellet was rinsed in 70% ethanol and resuspended in 20 [mu]l of hybridization buffer (0.4 M NaCl, 10 mM PIPES pH 6.4, 1 mM Na 4 EDTA). After heating for 15 min at 70oC, hybridization of the labelled primers to mtRNAs was achieved by a 3-4 h incubation at 42oC. Primer extension was carried out in a final volume of 200 [mu]l with 40 [mu]l of 5* Mu-MLV buffer (250 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.3, 375 mM KCl, 50 mM DTT and 15 mM MgCl 2 ), 200 U of reverse transcriptase (Mu-MLV, Gibco-BRL), 10 [mu]l of each dNTP (10 mM) and 125 [mu]g/ml actinomycin D. After 1 h of incubation at 37oC, RNase A (20 mg/ml) was added for 30 min at 37oC. The DNA-RNA duplexes were ethanol precipitated, denatured by heating 10 min at 70oC, analyzed in a 6% denaturing polyacrylamide gel and autoradiographed. The sequence of the M13mp19 plasmid (obtained with the M13 universal primer) was used as marker for product size estimation.

Nuclease S1 protection

To map 5' (Fig. 1 C) and 3' transcript termini (Fig. 2 ), nuclease S1 experiments were performed as described in ( 19 ). Synthesis of the single-stranded uniformly labelled probe in Figure 1 C was performed using the subcloned Spe I- Apa I restriction fragment of KS5.3 (containing the nad3 - nad1/A intergenic region and part of nad1/A coding sequence) as template and the primer O4 (complementary to the 5' coding region of nad1/A ). This probe was linearized at its 5' end with Spe I. In Figure 2 , the probes corresponding to the nad1/A downstream region were synthesized using the subcloned Apa I- Pst I and the Pst I- Kpn I fragments of KS5.3 as templates and the M13 universal primer. The two probes were linearized at their 5' end with Dra I and Pst I respectively. Product sizes were determined in comparison with the sequence of M13mp18 plasmid.


Figure 1 . Identification of 5' transcript termini upstream of each coding sequence in the two gene clusters. (A, B and D) Primer extension analysis of the upstream regions of orf87, nad3 and rps12 was performed using primers O1, O3 and O5 respectively. (C) Mapping of a 5' transcript terminus within the nad3-nad1/A intergenic region by nuclease S1 protection was performed using an O4- Spe I single-stranded labelled probe. Product sizes were estimated by co-migration of the M13mp19 plasmid sequence. The size of the products are noted in nucleotides and the position of the corresponding transcript termini in regards to the start codon of orf87 are given into brackets. The coding sequences (black boxes), the primers (horizontal arrows), the labelled probe used in (C) (white bar) as well as the positions of the 5' transcript termini (vertical arrows) are represented on schematic restriction maps of the two genomic regions. Restriction sites are symbolized as follows: A: Apa I, B: Bam HI, C: Cla I, D: Dra I, E: Eco RI, K: Kpn I, P: Pst I, S: Sac I, Sa: Sal I, Sh: Sph I, Sp: Spe I, X: Xho I, Xb: Xba I.


Figure 2 . Mapping of two transcript 3' termini in the downstream region of nad1/A. Nuclease S1 protection assays were performed using two different single-stranded labelled probes synthesized with the ( A ) Apa I- Pst I fragment of KS5.3 as template and (B) Pst I- Kpn I fragment of KS5.3 as template. (C) The termination site T2 located 188 bp downstream of nad1/A can be folded into a double stem-loop secondary structure proposed to act in the stabilization of transcripts. The single-stranded labelled probes are represented with white bars.


Figure 3 . Identification of a transcription initiation site, located 213 bp upstream of orf87 in the two loci. (A) Schematic display of subfragments of KS5.3 and KS7 submitted to hybridization with in vitro cap-labelled mtRNAs (subclones 1-4 and Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI restriction digests). These fragments are indicated with black bars. Southern hybridization of (B) clones 1-4 and of (C) the Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI digests of KS5.3 and KS7 with in vitro cap-labelled mtRNAs. (D) RNase protection experiment using cap-labelled mtRNAs and an antisense RNA corresponding to clone 1. In order to test their integrity, capped RNAs (lane 1) were run in parallel with the reaction product (lane 2).




In vitro capping of mt RNAs and RNase protection

In vitro capping and RNase protection experiments (Fig. 3 ) were carried out according to the protocol described in ( 20 ). Protected products were run in a 6% denaturing polyacrylamide gel with the standard M13mp18 sequence.

Phosphorylation of mtRNAs

Nicotiana sylvestris mtRNAs (50-75 [mu]g) were labelled in a final volume of 40 [mu]l containing 4 [mu]l of 10* polynucleotide kinase buffer, 40 U of polynucleotide kinase (Gibco-BRL), 80 U of RNase Inhibitor and 100 [mu]Ci [[gamma]- 32 P]ATP (3000 Ci/mmol). The reaction was incubated 1 h at 37oC and samples were treated as the capped RNAs.

In vitro transcription

In vitro run-off transcription assays were performed as in ( 10 ). Transcription products were electrophoresed in a 5% denaturing polyacrylamide gel in parallel with a labelled pGEM DNA marker (Promega). The satp9XR482 clone containing the soybean atp9 gene promoter region and linearized with Kpn I ( 10 ) was used as a positive control.

Primers

Positions of the primers given into brackets refer to the sequences of KS5.3 (DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank no. X96741) and KS7 (X96742). O1, O2, O3, O6, O7, O8 and O9 coordinates refer to either X96741 or X96742; O4 coordinates refer to X96741 and O5 to X96742. The position 0 corresponds to the start codon of the orf87 coding sequence. Primers O1, O2, O3 and O5 were used in primer extension analysis (Fig. 1 A, B and D) and primer O4 in nuclease S1 protection (Fig. 1 C). Primers O2, O4, O6, O7, O8 and O9 were used in order to obtain the PCR subfragments of KS5.3. O1 (-142/-159) 5'-TTTTTATTATGATTGGGC-3' O2 (51/34) 5'-GCATGACCAGAAGAATTG-3' O3 (762/745) 5'-GGCGTTTTCCTGGCTTAG-3' O4 (1470/1453) 5'-AACAGCTATGTACATTTT-3' O5 (1322/1303) 5'-GATTTTTTGTAGGCATCGCT-3' O6 (-1206/-1189) 5'-GAGGTCCTCTCCTTACAG-3' O7 (179/196) 5'-GCTTGCTAACTCTTGGAT-3' O8 (907/890) 5'-GACATCACCACAGAAAAC-3' O9 (1259/1276) 5'-ACCACTAGTGAGAGGGCA-3'

RESULTS

The region upstream of orf87 is conserved near several mt genes

In the fertile line of N.sylvestris , we previously described two mt gene clusters, the orf87-nad3-nad1/A and the orf87-nad3-rps12 cistrons, localized on two Sac I restriction fragments of 5.3 and 7 kb respectively ( 15 ). The sequence data of both genomic regions (DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank nos X96741 and X96742) revealed that the 60 first nt of orf87 are similar to several plant mt chimeric orfs ( 15 ). In a first step towards identification of a potential promoter element, we sequenced the clone 1 containing the 1.2 kb upstream region of orf87 (data not shown). Sequencing data confirmed previous Southern hybridization and restriction mapping indicating that the orf87 upstream region is identical in both gene clusters. Moreover, strong similarity was found between the upstream region of N.sylvestris orf87 and the upstream regions of other mt genes: the proximal 128 nt showed 98% identity with the 5' regions of rps13 and atp6 genes in tobacco ( 12 , 21 ) and partial similarity with the sequences upstream of the Petunia S-pcf chimeric gene ( 22 ), of the Oenothera and sunflower orfB ( 23 , 24 ) and of Brassica napus orf158 and orf224 ( 25 , 26 ).

Mapping of the 5 ' and 3 ' transcript termini in both loci

The 5' ends of transcripts were mapped using primer extension and nuclease S1 experiments, which allow detection of both initiation and processing sites. Primer extension was used to map transcript extremities in the upstream regions of orf87 (primers O1 and O2; Fig. 1 A), of nad3 (primer O3; Fig. 1 B) and rps12 (primer O5; Fig. 1 D). Nuclease S1 protection was used to map 5' transcript ends in the upstream region of nad1/A (primer O4; Fig. 1 C). Primer O2 gave abundant and large products, whose sizes were difficult to estimate but no signal was visible between the orf87 start codon and the Apa I site (data not shown). Primer O1 spanning the Apa I site yielded two main signals corresponding to products of 72 nt (site S1: position -213 with regards to the ATG codon of orf87 ) and 35/40 nt (site S2: position -175/-180). Another 5' RNA extremity was mapped 481/484 bp upstream of nad3 with primer O3 (site S3: position 418/421). On the other hand, nuclease S1 protection, using the O4- Spe I single-stranded labelled probe spanning the nad1/A upstream region, gave two major signals. One of 208 nt corresponded to the size of the probe which is thus fully protected by nad3 - nad1 / A co-transcripts. A second shorter product of 80-85 nt indicated a 5' transcript end located 65/70 bp upstream of nad1 / A open reading frame (site S4: position 1386/1391). Primer extension using primer O5 located near the rps12 start codon yielded a major product of 46/52 nt corresponding to a 5' site located 30/36 bp upstream of rps12 (site S5: position 1271/1277).

3' termini of the orf87-nad3-nad1/A transcripts were mapped by nuclease S1 protection. Uniformly labelled probes corresponding to the Pst I- Apa I and Kpn I- Pst I subfragments downstream of nad1 / A were synthesized, restricted with Dra I and Pst I respectively and hybridized with mtRNAs. After nuclease S1 treatment, two products of 193 nt ( Apa I- Pst I template; Fig. 2 A) and 259 nt ( Pst I- Kpn I template; Fig. 2 B) were obtained corresponding to sites located 188 bp (site T2: position 2373) and 785 bp (site T1: position 2970) downstream of the nad1/ A stop codon. This 5' and 3' transcript termini mapping correlates well to the transcription patterns obtained in northern experiments using orf87 , nad3 and nad1/A ( 15 ). Indeed the 3200 and 2700 nt RNA species detected with the three probes could correspond to the sizes expected for large co-transcripts beginning at site S1 and ending at termination sites T1 and T2 respectively.

The site S1 localized upstream of orf87 corresponds to a transcription initiation site

Primary mitochondrial RNAs are not capped during in vivo maturation and can be capped in vitro using guanylyltransferase. This enzyme recognizes these transcripts with free tri- or biphosphate 5' extremities, but not processed mtRNAs with a monophosphate extremity. In order to get preliminary information on the localization of potential transcription initiation sites, in vitro cap-labelled total mtRNAs were hybridized to Southern blots carrying different regions covering each gene cluster, i.e. clones 1-4 (corresponding to the upstream regions of orf87, nad3, nad1/A and rps12 respectively) and the Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI restriction digests from KS5.3 and KS7 (Fig. 3 A). A signal was observed with clone 1 containing the sites S1 and S2, but not with clones 2, 3 and 4 (Fig. 3 B). Hybridization was also detected with the 1 kb Sac I- Apa I region upstream of orf87 and the Sac I- Bam HI fragment of 1.75 kb containing the sites S1 and S2 (Fig. 3 C). Analogous results were obtained with the Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI digests of KS7 (Fig. 3 C). Taken together, these data suggest that in both gene clusters, transcription initiation sites are located in the upstream region of orf87 and that no additional initiation site exists.

As a confirmation, capped mtRNAs were hybridized to an antisense single-stranded RNA complementary to clone 1 (linearized at the Hin dIII site of the plasmid multiple cloning site) and the RNA-RNA duplex was submitted to RNase digestion. A protected product of 225 nt was obtained (Fig. 3 D, lane 2) which corresponds exactly to the site S1, located 213 nt upstream of orf87 . This site thus seems to function as a transcription initiation site.

In order to confirm the capping data, phosphorylation of mtRNAs was performed. Since primary transcripts have bi- or triphosphate extremities, only the processed mtRNAs with 5' monophosphate extremities will be labelled by a polynucleotide kinase activity. Phosphorylated mtRNAs were hybridized to Southern blots of clones 1-4 and all clones except clone 1 displayed a signal (Fig. 4 A). In the Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI restriction digests of KS5.3 and KS7, all fragments except the 1 kb Sac I- Apa I and the 1.75 kb Sac I- Bam HI fragments hybridized to the phosphorylated mt RNAs (Fig. 4 B). Phosphorylation experiments thus confirm the in vitro capping analysis, suggesting that the site S1 is an initiation site and that S3, S4 and S5 are processing sites.

The site S1 initiates in vitro transcription in a heterologous mt lysate


Figure 4 . Processed transcript termini are found upstream of nad3 , nad1/A and rps12 . Subfragments of KS5.3 and KS7 submitted to hybridization with phosphorylated mtRNAs are identical to those in Figure 3A. Southern hybridization of (A) clones 1-4 and (B) the Sac I- Apa I and Sac I- Bam HI digests of KS5.3 and KS7, with in vitro phosphorylated mtRNAs. While it is assumed that cappable 5' ends represent bona fide initiation sites, exceptions have been reported in which bi- or triphosphate ends of transcripts are created in vivo as a result of processing events ( 27 ). Such exceptions justify the need for functional assays by means of in vitro or in vivo systems. Experiments using N.sylvestris and Solanum tuberosum mt protein extracts were unsuccessful, rendering necessary the use of a heterologous system. An efficient in vitro transcription system from pea seedling mitochondria was recently described ( 10 ). In this system, the partially purified proteins were able to initiate specific transcription using heterologous soybean and Oenothera templates. In order to get functional evidence for the presence of a transcription initiation site, N.sylvestris clones 1, 2, 3 and 5 ( rps12 upstream region) were tested as templates in run-off transcription (Fig. 5 A). The soybean atp9 promoter (template used as positive control, linearized with Kpn I) gave the expected 280 nt transcription product (Fig. 5 B and C). As previously shown ( 10 ), only the 20-50% ammonium sulphate-precipitated protein fraction eluted from the ion-exchange chromatography column with 250 mM KCl allowed specific transcription (Fig. 5 B). For N.sylvestris templates, a run-off product was obtained with clone 1 restricted with Hin dIII (Fig. 5 B and C). The size of 260 nt was that expected if the site S1 would be used as a specific transcription initiation site. No signal corresponding to the S2 site could be evidenced and no run-off transcription products were observed with clones 2, 3 and 5 in two independent experiments (Fig. 5 C).


Figure 5 . The site S1 only is able to initiate specific in vitro transcription in a heterologous system. (A) Nicotiana sylvestris templates were clones 1, 2, 3 and 5, linearized with Hin dIII, Eco RI, Kpn I and Eco RI respectively. The run-off products, expected if all 5' RNA termini were initiation sites, are symbolized by dotted arrows and their theoretical sizes are indicated. (B) Gel analysis of in vitro transcription assays with two fractions of the pea mt protein extracts, i.e. the 20-50% ammonium sulfate precipitated protein fractions eluted with 250 and 300 mM KCl respectively from the ion exchange column. The Kpn I-linearized satp9XR482 clone of soybean ( S-atp9 ) as positive control (10) and the N.sylvestris Hin dIII-linearized clone 1 (1) were tested. (C) Gel analysis of run-off transcription products obtained with N.sylvestris clones 1-5 as templates. Run-off product sizes are indicated in nucleotides and estimated in comparison with the labelled pGEM DNA marker (L).

DISCUSSION

Co-transcription of mitochondrial genes encoding polypeptides involved in different functional pathways and present in different amounts creates unique regulatory difficulties. The mt orf87- nad3-nad1/A and orf87-nad3-rps12 cistrons in N.sylvestris were investigated as examples of such units. In these gene clusters, nad1 and nad3 encode subunits of the NADH: ubiquinol oxidoreductase involved in the mt respiratory process, while rps12 encodes a polypeptide of the small ribosomal subunit, known to be essential in the translational apparatus ( 28 ). Whereas the orf87-nad3-nad1/A cistron appears to be specific of the Nicotiana genus ( 15 ), it is noteworthy that the nad3 - rps12 association is conserved in all higher plants tested so far. Such conserved organization is also observed for the rrn18 - rrn5 and rps3-rpl16 gene clusters which appear to have a functional significance, as the associated genes are all involved in the mitochondrial translational apparatus. The conservation of the nad3 - rps12 cluster could be explained by structural arguments, i.e. no homologous recombination has occurred within the nad3 - rps12 intergenic region during plant evolution (except in the Nicotiana genus; 15 ), because of its small size or uniqueness of its sequence. Another possibility is that this gene association displays a functional significance in plant mitochondria, but neither quantitative nor functional correlation between nad3 and rps12 transcripts or polypeptides has been reported to date.

The expression of both gene clusters is under the control of a transcription initiation site, located in the orf87 upstream region

Primer extension experiments revealed two signals (S1 and S2) in the upstream region of orf87 in both gene clusters. Sequencing of this region showed that a 128 bp sequence located upstream of orf87 displays homology with the upstream regions of other mt genes and orfs. Such a conservation suggests that it might play an important role in the expression of these coding sequences. Since the sites S1 and S2 are located outside this conserved region (as they were found 213 and 175 bp upstream of orf87 respectively ) we assume that, if the conserved region plays a role, it may be involved in the post-transcriptional maturation of the transcripts or in the translational processes. The nature of the site S2 is not clear, since taken together all experimental data show that it is neither an initiation site nor a processing site. Furthermore, sequence analysis of this site did not reveal the presence of any potential promoter element. Since the S2 signal was repeatedly found, we can suggest either that a secondary structure leads to the premature stop of the reverse transcriptase or, that the primer O1 could partially prime another transcript and thus allow the synthesis of the observed short reverse transcription product.

In vitro capping and transcription experiments showed that the site S1 is a transcription initiation site. Sequence of the region surrounding this site fits the consensus proposed for dicotyledonous mt promoters by comparision of rrn , trn but also atp and cox genes from Oenothera , pea and soybean ( 36 ): Scheme 1.

Few data are available concerning mt gene promoters in solanaceous species, as capping experiments have only been performed for the S.tuberosum trnS-trnF-trnP cistron and for the atp9 and rrn26 genes ( 20 , 29 , 30 ) . In these cases, the transcription initiation sites do not display similarity with the dicotyledonous consensus sequence. We show here that a promoter with this consensus exists in a solanaceous species and that it is used for transcription of both nad and rps genes. Moreover this promoter element is able to initiate transcription in a pea in vitro system. Among promoter regions described to date in dicots, only the 20-30 bp consensus sequence surrounding the initiation site and adjacent AT-rich regions have been shown to play a role in mitochondrial transcription initiation, but no additional activator or inhibitor element has yet been reported ( 3 , 7 , 10 ). Nevertheless such regulatory elements are likely to be present since run-on transcription assays showed that genes displayed different transcription rates in plant mitochondria ( 28 , 31 ). In vitro transcription systems, like the pea one, are thus expected to allow the investigation of potential 5' and/or 3' regulatory motifs, by comparing genes with different transcription rates or tissue-specific expression ( 32 , 33 ).

In contrast with wheat or rice, the expression of nad3 and rps12 genes in N.sylvestris appears to be controlled exclusively by the orf87 promoter region. In wheat, a pseudo-tRNA ([Psi]-tRNA Phe ) is located upstream and co-transcribed with the nad3-rps12 unit ( 34 ). Two orfs located downstream of rps12 also belong to the cistron ( 35 ). Primer extension experiments detected at least two putative transcript extremities in the 5' region of nad3 , one upstream of the [Psi]-tRNA Phe gene and a second within the [Psi]-tRNA Phe coding sequence. Unfortunately capping experiments were not performed and the function of these sites remains unclear. In rice, nad3 and rps12 are located downstream of and are co-transcribed with the rps3-rpl16 gene cluster ( 14 ). Capping experiments revealed two alternative promoters, one upstream of rps3 leading to a large polycistronic transcript and another allowing independent transcription of the nad3 - rps12 cluster.

Processing and termination sites in both cistrons

The mechanisms of RNA processing in plant mitochondria are still little understood ( 36 ). Some data are available concerning tRNA and rRNA processing ( 3 , 37 ) but very little is known about mRNA maturation. In N.sylvestris , we have shown that the 5' transcript termini detected upstream of nad3 (site S3), nad1/A (site S4) and rps12 (site S5) are assumed to be processing sites since they yielded no signal in either capping or in vitro transcription experiments. Furthermore, complementary hybridization of in vitro phosphorylated mtRNAs as probe to DNA fragments containing these sites supports the idea that they indeed correspond to processed RNA extremities. The sequences at and around these sites are divergent and do not display any similarity with conserved sequences of published processing sites ( 38 , 39 ). In addition, two different transcript 3' termini (called T1 and T2) were localized in the nad1/A downstream region. These 3' ends are also very divergent and they do not show primary sequence similarity with termination or processing sites of mt genes from other species ( 40 - 42 ). According to the divergence of the primary sequences near all these sites, even within the same species, it is very difficult to speculate about the mechanism and specificity of processing or termination. Nevertheless 3' terminal secondary structures have been proposed either to characterize transcription termination as in bacteria ( 43 ) or to play a role in mRNA processing or transcript stabilization as in the chloroplast ( 44 ). In this study, a stem-loop structure could be folded at the site T2 only (Fig. 2 ). The strong intensity of nuclease S1 signal suggests that transcripts ending at this site can accumulate in N.sylvestris mitochondria and supports the idea of a functional importance of such secondary structure in tobacco mitochondria. On the other hand, previous northern experiments ( 15 ) revealed strong signals for transcripts assumed to be ending at the processing sites S3, S4 or at the termination site T1. Since these sites do not display particular secondary structures, it may be proposed that alternative factors and/or other motifs could play a role in mRNA processing and stabilization, such as RNA binding proteins which have already been found in the chloroplast ( 45 ).

As no initiation site was identified within the different intergenic regions, we assume that nad3 , nad1/A and rps12 are exclusively expressed as polycistronic cotranscripts in N.sylvestris . Similar results were obtained for the nad3-rps12 association in wheat and rice ( 35 , 13 ) as well as in the maize co-transcribed rrn18 and rrn5 genes ( 4 ). Nevertheless posttranscriptional maturation of the primary transcripts encoded by the nad3-rps12 gene clusters appears to differ between species. Indeed our results suggest that, in N.sylvestris, nad3 and rps12 monocistronic transcripts can be produced as one processing site was detected in their intergenic region. In contrast, nad3-rps12 dicistronic transcripts but no monocistronic RNA were identified in wheat mitochondria. In this case, the authors reported the presence of a Pribnow motif between the two genes but no processing site ( 34 ). Thus, although the nad3-rps12 gene association is highly conserved in plants, the flanking co-transcribed sequences as well as the expression patterns differ significantly between species.

In conclusion, we have shown that in N.sylvestris , (i) the expression of two different gene clusters is controlled by a promoter element fitting the dicotyledonous consensus and (ii) the production of the monocistronic transcripts requires multiple processing events of the large primary transcripts. Such data confirm that, specially for such co-transcriptional units that contain genes belonging to different complexes or pathways, the post-transcriptional mechanisms are particularly important to regulate the stoichiometry of the transcripts and of the encoded polypeptides in plant mitochondria.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

C.L. was supported in part by a short-term fellowship from the European Molecular Biology Organization. C.R. was a Senior Research Assistant from the Belgian Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique. We wish to thank C. Colas des Francs-Small for reading of the manuscript and R. de Paepe for helpful discussions.

REFERENCES

1 Clayton,D.A. (1991) Annu. Rev. Cell. Biol., 7, 453-478. MEDLINE Abstract

2 Kennell,J.C. and Lambovitz,A.M. (1989) Mol. Cell. Biol., 9, 3603-3613. MEDLINE Abstract

3 Gray,M.W., Hanic-Joyce,P.J. and Covello,P.S. (1992) Plant Mol. Biol., 43, 145-175.

4 Mulligan,R.M., Maloney,A.P. and Walbot,V. (1988) Mol. Gen. Genet., 211, 373-380. MEDLINE Abstract

5 Mulligan,R.M., Lau,G.T. and Walbot,V. (1988) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 85, 7998-8002. MEDLINE Abstract

6 Rapp,W.D. and Stern,D.B. (1991) EMBO J., 11, 1065-1073.

7 Rapp,W.D., Lupold,D.S., Mack,S. and Stern,D.B. (1993) Mol. Cell. Biol., 13, 7232-7238. MEDLINE Abstract

8 Binder,S. and Brennnicke,A. (1993) J. Biol. Chem., 268, 7849-7855. MEDLINE Abstract

9 Binder,S. and Brennicke,A. (1993) Nucleic Acids Res., 21, 5012-5019. MEDLINE Abstract

10 Binder,S., Hatzack,F. and Brennicke,A. (1995) J. Biol. Chem., 270, 1-8.

11 Hanson,M.R. and Folkerts,O. (1992) Int. Rev. Cyt., 141, 129-172.

12 Bland,M.M., Levings,C.S.,III and Matzinger,D.F. (1986) Mol. Gen. Genet., 204, 8-16. MEDLINE Abstract

13 Liu,A.W., Narayanan,K.K., André,C.P., Kaleikau,E.K. and Walbot,V. (1992) Curr. Genet., 21, 507-513. MEDLINE Abstract

14 Nakazono,M., Itadani,H., Wakasugi,T., Tsutsumi,N., Sugiura,M. and Hirai,A. (1995) Curr. Genet., 27, 184-189. MEDLINE Abstract

15 Gutierres,S., Lelandais,C., De Paepe,R., Vedel,F. and Chetrit,P. Curr. Genet., in press.

16 Sambrook,J., Frisch,E.F. and Maniatis,T. (1989) Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY.

17 Stern,D.B. and Newton,K.J. (1986) Methods Enzymol., 118, 488-496. MEDLINE Abstract

18 Maréchal-Drouard,L., Weil,J.H. and Dietrich,A. (1995) Methods Enzymol., 260, 310-327.

19 Ausubel,F.M., Brent,R., Kingston,R.E., Moore,D.D., Siedman,J.G., Smith,J.A. and Struhl,K. (1987) Current Protocols in Molecular Biology. Wiley-Interscience, NY.

20 Remacle,C. and Maréchal-Drouard,L. (1996) Plant Mol. Biol., 30, 553-563. MEDLINE Abstract

21 Bland,M.M., Levings,C.S.,III and Matzinger,D.F. (1987) Curr. Genet., 12, 475-481. MEDLINE Abstract

22 Pruitt,K.D. and Hanson,M. (1989) Curr. Genet., 16, 281-291. MEDLINE Abstract

23 Hiesel,R., Schobel,W., Schuster,W. and Brennicke,A. (1987) EMBO J., 6, 29-34.

24 Quagliariello,C., Saiardi,A. and Gallerani,R. (1990) Curr. Genet., 18, 355-363. MEDLINE Abstract

25 Bonhomme,S., Budar,F., Lancelin,D., Small,I., Defrance,M.C. and Pelletier,G. (1992) Mol. Gen. Genet., 235, 340-348. MEDLINE Abstract

26 Singh,M. and Brown,G.G. (1991) Plant Cell, 3, 1349-1362. MEDLINE Abstract

27 L'Abbé,D., Lang.B.F., Desjardins,P. and Morais,R. (1990) J. Biol. Chem., 265, 2988-2992.

28 Muise,R.C. and Hauswirth,W.W. (1992) Curr. Genet., 22, 235-242. MEDLINE Abstract

29 Lizama,L., Holuigue,L. and Jordana,X. (1994) FEBS Lett., 349, 243-248. MEDLINE Abstract

30 Binder,S., Thalheim,C. and Brennicke,A. (1994) Curr. Genet., 26, 519-523. MEDLINE Abstract

31 Mulligan,R.M., Leon,P. and Walbot,V. (1991) Mol. Cell. Biol., 11, 533-543. MEDLINE Abstract

32 Conley,C.A. and Hanson,M.R. (1994) Plant Cell, 6, 85-91.

33 Smart,C.J., Moneger,F. and Leaver,C.J. (1994) Plant Cell, 6, 811-825. MEDLINE Abstract

34 Gualberto,J.-M., Wintz,H., Weil,J.H. and Grienenberger,J.-M. (1988) Mol. Gen. Genet., 215, 118-127. MEDLINE Abstract

35 Gualberto,J.-M., Bonnard,G., Lamattina,L. and Grienenberger,J.-M. (1991) Plant Cell, 3, 1109-1120. MEDLINE Abstract

36 Gray,M.W. (1992) Int. Rev. of Cytology, 141, 233-357.

37 Marchfelder,A. and Brennicke,A. (1994) Plant Physiol., 105, 1247-1254. MEDLINE Abstract

38 Schuster,W. and Brennicke,A. (1989) Curr. Genet., 15, 187-192. MEDLINE Abstract

39 Laser,B. and Kück,U. (1995) Curr. Genet., 29, 50-57. MEDLINE Abstract

40 Conklin,P.L., Wilson,R.K. and Hanson,M.R. (1991) Genes Dev., 5, 1407-1415. MEDLINE Abstract

41 Chapdelaine,Y. and Bonen,L. (1991) Cell, 65, 465-472. MEDLINE Abstract

42 Wissinger,B., Schuster,W. and Brennicke,A. (1991) Cell, 65, 473-482. MEDLINE Abstract

43 Schuster,W., Hiesel,R., Isaac,P.G., Leaver,C.J. and Brennicke,A. (1986) Nucleic Acids Res., 14, 5943-5954. MEDLINE Abstract

44 Stern,D.B. and Gruissem,W. (1987) Cell, 51, 1145-1157. MEDLINE Abstract

45 Stern,D.B. and Gruissem,W. (1989) J. Biol. Chem., 264, 18742-18750. MEDLINE Abstract


Return

*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel: +33 1 69 33 64 07; Fax: 33 1 69 33 64 25; Email: chetrit@ibp.u-psud.fr
Add to CiteULike CiteULike   Add to Connotea Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us Del.icio.us    What's this?



This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Print PDF (247K) Freely available
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to My Personal Archive
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowRequest Permissions
Right arrow Commercial Re-use Guidelines
for Open Access NAR Content
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Lelandais, C
Right arrow Articles by Chetrit, P
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Lelandais, C
Right arrow Articles by Chetrit, P
Social Bookmarking
 Add to CiteULike   Add to Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us  
What's this?