ABSTRACT
Endonuclease IV of
Escherichia coli
has been implicated by genetic studies in the repair of DNA damage caused by the antitumor drug bleomycin, but the lesion(s) recognized by this
enzyme
in vivo
have not been identified. We used the sensitive primer activation assay, which monitors the formation of 3
'
-OH groups that support
in vitro
synthesis by
E.coli
DNA polymerase I, to determine whether endonuclease IV-specific damage could be detected in the chromosomal DNA of cells lacking
the enzyme after
in vivo
treatment with bleomycin. Chromosomal DNA isolated after a 1 h bleomycin
treatment from wild-type, endonuclease IV-deficient (
nfo
-) and endonuclease IV-overproducing (p-nfo;
~
10-fold) strains all supported modest polymerase activity. However,
in vitro
treatment with purified endonuclease IV activated subsequent DNA synthesis with samples
from the
nfo
- strain (an average of 2.6-fold), to a lesser extent for samples from wild-type cells (2.1-fold), and still less for the p-nfo samples (1.5-fold). This pattern is consistent with the presence of unrepaired damage that
correlates inversely with the
in vivo
activity of endonuclease IV. Incubation of the DNA from bleomycin-treated
nfo
- cells with polymerase and dideoxynucleoside triphosphates lowered the endonuclease IV-independent priming activity, but did not affect the amount of activation seen after
endonuclease IV treatment. Primer activation with DNA from the
nfo
- strain could also be obtained with purified
E.coli
exonuclease III
in vitro
, but a quantitative comparison demonstrated that endonuclease IV was
>=
5-fold more active in this assay. Thus, endonuclease IV-specific damage can be detected after
in vivo
exposure to bleomycin. These may be 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose residues, but other possibilities are discussed.
Bleomycin (BLM) is a glycopeptide antibiotic that is a clinically important
antitumor agent (
1
). The cytostasis and cytotoxicity caused by BLM is thought to be due to base
elimination and DNA strand scission by BLM (
2
). In the presence of Fe(II), BLM initiates DNA degradation
in vitro
by abstracting a hydrogen atom from C-4' of DNA deoxyribose (
3
), in a manner analogous to the action of hydroxyl radicals formed by ionizing
radiation or chemical oxidation (
4
,
5
). The products of this reaction are base propenals, DNA-5'-phosphates, and DNA-3'-phosphoglycolate esters (
3
,
6
). BLM also forms alkali-labile sites in DNA that are reminiscent of conventional
apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites, but have the deoxyribose C-4 oxidized to form 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose (
7
,
8
). In addition, the degradation of DNA-RNA hybrids by BLM leads to alkali-labile sites that are oxidized at deoxyribose C-1 (
9
).
In crude extracts of
Escherichia coli
, exonuclease III accounts for most (85-90%) of the total DNA-3'-repair diesterase/AP endonuclease activity, and
endonuclease IV accounts for about half of the remainder (
10
-
12
). Endonuclease IV activity is induced by O
2
-
as part of the
soxRS
regulon for defense against oxygen radicals (
13
,
14
). Cells lacking endonuclease IV (
nfo
mutants) are clearly hypersensitive to BLM and
t
-butylhydroperoxide, modestly hypersensitive to methyl methane sulfonate and mitomycin C, but not to H
2
O
2
, UV light or [gamma]-rays (
15
). The hypersensitivity of exonuclease III-deficient cells (
xth
mutants) to many of these agents is further exaggerated by the introduction of
an
nfo
mutation (
15
), which suggests a `back-up' function for endonuclease IV in the repair of DNA damage formed by H
2
O
2
, X-rays, methyl methane sulfonate or mitomycin C. In contrast, BLM and
t
-butylhydroperoxide evidently generate DNA damages that specifically
require endonuclease IV, rather than exonuclease III, for their efficient
repair (
15
). Endonuclease IV-specific damage is also formed by nitric oxide exposure of
E.coli
, as shown by the hypersensitivity of
nfo
single mutants to killing by macrophages that generate this free radical gas (
16
).
Alkali-labile sites induced in DNA by BLM
in vitro
are cleaved by endonuclease IV at least five times more efficiently than by exonuclease III
(
17
-
19
). These sites are distinct from the C-1-oxidized residues formed in DNA by Cu(II)-phenanthroline (
18
). Indeed,
E.coli
endonuclease IV was independently identified in a search for nuclease
activities specific for BLM-damaged DNA (
19
). Thus, both genetic and
in vitro
biochemical data suggest a key role for endonuclease IV in the repair of
specific DNA damage not effectively handled by other enzymes. In the present
work, we demonstrate directly that endonuclease IV is specifically required for
the repair of certain types of BLM-induced DNA damage formed
in vivo
.
BW527 (
nfo::kan
; ref.
15
) was kindly provided by Dr Bernard Weiss (University of Michigan). Strain
AB1157 was a stock in our laboratory. Plasmid pKC7, containing the wild-type
nfo
gene expressed under its own promoter (
20
), was generously supplied by R. P. Cunningham (State University of New York,
Albany).
Endonuclease IV was purified as previously described (
11
) with appropriate modifications (
12
). Exonuclease III was purchased from New England BioLabs and DNA polymerase I was from Life Technologies Inc. (Gaithersburg, MD). Bleomycin sulfate (Blenoxane) was either purchased from Sigma or was a gift from the Bristol-Myers Co. BLM was dissolved in 10 mM HEPES-KOH, pH 7.6, at a concentration of 10 mg/ml, and the concentration of drug was checked using [epsilon]
290
= 14 000 M
-1
and a molecular weight for BLM of 1440 g/mol (
2
). Hydrogen peroxide was from Fluka, and paraquat, menadione,
t
-butylhydroperoxide and cumene hydroperoxide were from Sigma.
Cells were grown in overnight cultures at 37oC in M9 medium (
21
) supplemented with 1% glucose, 1% casamino acids, 1 mM MgSO
4
, 0.1 mM CaCl
2
, 1 [mu]g/ml thiamine and 100 [mu]g/ml of the appropriate antibiotic (streptomycin for AB1157, kanamycin
for BW527, and ampicillin for AB1157 pKC7). Cells were diluted into fresh
medium the next day, and grown to exponential phase (OD
600
= 0.2-0.6), then treated with drug (typically 50 [mu]g/[mu]l BLM in 10 ml cultures for 1 h at 37oC). Survivals were obtained by diluting cells into M9 medium, followed by plating onto
LB plates to determine colony-forming units (
21
,
22
). Cells were pelleted, washed with M9 salts, and frozen at -80oC.
Cell pellets were thawed on ice, suspended in 1 ml HE (10 mM HEPES-KOH, pH 7.6, 1 mM EDTA), followed by the addition of 200 [mu]g chick egg lysozyme and 0.34 [mu]g phage P22 lysozyme (a gift of Dr L. Hardy, University of Massachusetts Medical
Center), and continued incubation for 1 h on ice. Sodium dodecyl sulfate was then added to a final concentration (w/v) of 0.5% and incubation on ice was
continued for another hour. The DNA was extracted with phenol, then dialyzed
against 100-1000 volumes of HE containing 1 M NaCl, followed by HE containing 10 mM
NaCl. The dialyzed DNA was treated with 2 [mu]g RNase A (freshly boiled) and extracted first with phenol, and then with
water-saturated ether. NaCl was added to a final concentration of 0.5 M, and the
DNA was precipitated by the addition of 2 vol cold absolute ethanol. The DNA pellet after centrifugation was resuspended in a minimal volume (50 [mu]l/10 ml culture) of HE. DNA concentrations were determined using [epsilon]
260
= 7500 M
-1
.
For treatment of DNA with dideoxynucleoside triphosphates (ddNTPs), DNA samples
were split immediately after the second dialysis and before the RNase
treatment. The DNA was incubated in 20 mM HEPES-KOH pH 7.6, 10 mM MgCl
2
, 20 [mu]M of each of the four ddNTPs and 1 U
E.coli
DNA polymerase I; polymerase was not added to control samples. The reactions were incubated for 18 h at 37oC and DNA isolation was completed as described above.
Reactions (25 [mu]l) containing 50 mM HEPES-KOH, pH 7.6, 50 mM KCl, 50 [mu]g/ml bovine serum albumin, 1.55 nmol DNA and either 1 mM EDTA
(for endonuclease IV reactions) or 1 mM MgCl
2
(for reactions containing exonuclease III), and the indicated amounts of
enzyme, were incubated at 37oC for 30 min. Endonuclease IV was inactivated by heating the reaction at 70oC for 3 min, then addition of MgCl
2
to 1 mM. Exonuclease III was inactivated by the addition of EDTA to 1 mM
followed by incubation of the reaction at 70oC for 3 min. DNA synthesis reactions were performed essentially as
described (
10
), except that thiols were omitted from the polymerase reaction. For each
reaction, 1 U
E.coli
DNA polymerase I was used, and the specific radioactivity of [
3
H]dTTP was typically ~1000 c.p.m./pmol in the polymerase reactions. Endonuclease IV and
exonuclease III were assayed for DNA-3'-phosphoglycolaldehyde (PGA) diesterase activity as described
(
10
,
11
), except that the buffers described above were used for enzyme incubations in
order to allow a direct comparison between the two assays.
Cunningham
et al
. (
15
) demonstrated that a disruption of the
nfo
gene in
E.coli
confers hypersensitivity to BLM and to
t
-butyl hydroperoxide, under conditions of chronic exposure to the drugs.
E.coli nfo::kan
mutants also exhibited hypersensitivity to BLM during a transient liquid
challenge (Fig.
1
), although the effect (~2-fold greater killing rate in the
nfo
-
strain) was not as substantial as that observed during the chronic exposure
assay (
15
). Using a transient challenge assay, an
nfo::kan
strain showed the same sensitivity as wild-type
E.coli
to
t
-butyl hydroperoxide, paraquat, menadione, H
2
O
2
or cumene hydroperoxide (data not shown). Thus, the hypersensitivity of
nfo::kan
mutants to BLM and to
t
-butyl hydroperoxide is more apparent under chronic than under transient
exposure.
Chromosomal DNA was isolated from wild-type and endonuclease IV-deficient cells that had been treated with 50 [mu]g/ml BLM
in vivo
. The ability of purified endonuclease IV to activate primers for DNA repair
synthesis (
10
) on this DNA was measured. Endonuclease IV treatment led to a 2- to 3-fold activation of priming ability for DNA isolated from both
endonuclease IV-deficient cells (Fig.
2
A) and wild-type
E.coli
(Fig.
2
B). This result suggested that, under these conditions, endonuclease IV might be
limiting
in vivo
even in the wild-type case. We therefore introduced a multicopy plasmid (pKC7) containing
the
nfo
gene (
20
) into wild-type AB1157, generating an isogenic strain that overproduces endonuclease
IV ~10-fold over wild-type (data not shown), and the chromo- somal DNA was isolated from this strain following
in vivo
BLM treatment. Endonuclease IV treatment of this DNA (Fig.
2
C) led to significantly lower primer activation for repair synthesis than for
the DNA isolated from BLM-treated
nfo
-
cells (Fig.
2
A). Little or no DNA synthesis was observed with DNA isolated from untreated
cells, and purified endonuclease IV had little or no effect on this DNA (data
not shown). The greater activating effect of endonuclease IV on the DNA from
BLM-treated
nfo
-
cells compared to DNA from BLM-treated cells with multicopy
nfo
+
was observed consistently over many independent DNA preparations and assays (Table
0
). Although the activation pattern was consistent (compare last two columns of Table
0
), there was significant variation between sets of DNA preparations in both the
level of DNA synthesis observed for DNA not treated with endonuclease IV, and
in the absolute amount of activation produced by the enzyme treatment (Table
1
). Such variation could result from differences in the amount of DNA damage
caused by BLM or the amount of repair that occurred during the 1 h exposure.
Figure
The observations presented here are consistent with previous
in vitro
experiments
(
17
-
19
), although the preference for endonuclease IV over exonuclease III in the
repair of BLM-induced DNA damage was less dramatic in the present studies. There are at
least three factors in our
in vivo
experiments which could mask a stronger preference for endonuclease IV over
other enzymes in cleaving at BLM-induced DNA damage sites. First, endonuclease IV, even when overproduced
10-fold, may not completely repair DNA damage
in vivo
during incubation with BLM, because some further activation of primers by endonuclease IV was observed (Fig.
2
B). Secondly, BLM
in vivo
may form a different distribution or collection of DNA damages than
in vitro
treatment, and some of these may be substrates for exonuclease III
in vitro
. Thirdly, the DNA extraction procedures might have generated substrates for
exonuclease III that were not present
in vivo
, a possibility that could be addressed by exploring different extraction
procedures.
A limited number of structures have been identified as BLM-induced damages in DNA (Fig.
5
), including DNA-3'-phosphoglycolates (
3
), 4'-oxidized AP sites (
7
,
8
), and 1'-oxidized AP sites which may form under specialized conditions (
9
). The primer-activation assay for endonuclease IV and exonuclease III does not
distinguish between 3'-blocking groups and abasic sites in DNA. However, DNA-3'-phosphoglycolates are cleaved at the same rate
as DNA-3'- PGA by both endonuclease IV and exonuclease III
in vitro
(J. Dorfman, J. Levin and B. Demple, unpublished results), and so are unlikely
to be the endonuclease IV-specific DNA damage suggested by the experiments of Figure
3
. We also attempted to address this point by estimating DNA strand breakage
using gel electrophoresis as performed for H
2
O
2
-treated
xth
strains (
10
), but we did not observe a significant difference in the fragmentation of the
chromosomal DNA between the multicopy
nfo
+
and the
nfo
-
strains after BLM treatment (data not shown). The smaller effect of
nfo
on BLM sensitivity (~2-fold) than of
xth
on H
2
O
2
sensitivity (~20-fold) suggests that such a difference might be difficult to observe.
Figure
Häring
et al
. (
18
) observed that the 1'-oxidized AP sites produced by Cu(II)-phenanthroline are not preferentially cleaved
in vitro
by endonuclease IV compared to exonuclease III. Therefore, a good candidate for the preferential endonuclease IV substrate
produced by BLM is the 4'-oxidized AP site, 2-deoxy-pentos-4-ulose (
7
,
8
). It is not yet clear from our results or those of others how much the relative
efficiency of endonuclease IV and exonuclease III for the various BLM-induced damage sites is influenced by the presence of other damage sites
nearby (
23
) or by the local DNA structure. This determination awaits the development of
synthetic DNA substrates containing site-specific 4'-oxidized abasic lesions.
The biological consequences of 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose residues in DNA have been only partially explored. This
lesion is formed by ionizing radiation (
5
), and mutants lacking both exonuclease III and endonuclease IV are
hypersensitive to X-rays (
15
). The wild-type X-ray resistance displayed by
nfo
-
single mutants suggests that exonuclease III can replace endonuclease IV for
repair of 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose in irradiated DNA, or that another radiation-induced lethal lesion predominates that is not
differentially recognized by these enzymes. BLM treatment produces complex
damage sites with 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose residues juxtaposed to oxidative strand breaks in the
opposite strand (
17
,
2
3
), which might well have a differential effect on cleavage by endonuclease IV
and exonuclease III. It is unknown whether the same structures are formed by
ionizing radiation (
5
). Precise and sensitive methods to quantitate 2-deoxypentos-4-ulose and other oxidized abasic sites are needed to define the
biological effects of the damage.
+
Present address: Technical Manufacturing, Life Technologies, Inc., 7335
Executive Way, Frederick, MD 21704, USA

Bacterial mutants deficient in endonuclease IV activity are hypersensitive to BLM under a variety of conditions (
15
,
22
; Fig.
1
). Chromosomal DNA isolated from enzyme-deficient mutants treated with BLM contains sites that can be activated as
primers for repair synthesis
in vitro
by treatment of the DNA with purified endonuclease IV, and the content of these
activatable primer sites was substantially lower in a strain overproducing
endonuclease IV. Moreover, endonuclease IV
in vitro
was ~5-fold more efficient in this primer activation than was exonuclease
III. These results indicate that BLM generates
in vivo
DNA damage
in
E.coli
that specifically requires endonuclease IV for its efficient repair and which
can be recovered from the cells for analysis. These results and various
published studies (
15
,
22
) do not exclude the possibility that exonuclease III might substitute
inefficiently
in vivo
for the loss of endonuclease IV.

REFERENCES
Return

