ABSTRACT
Oligonucleotide N3
' ->
P5
'
phosphoramidates are a new and promising class of antisense agents. Here we
report biological properties of phosphoramidate oligonucleotides targeted
against the human T cell leukemia virus type-I Tax protein, the major transcriptional transactivator of this human
retrovirus. Isosequential phosphorothioate oligodeoxynucleotides and uniformly
modified and chimeric phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides containing six
central phosphodiester linkages are all quite stable in cell nuclei. The
uniformly modified anti-
tax
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotide does not activate nuclear RNase H, as was
shown by RNase protection assay. In contrast, the chimeric phosphoramidate-phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotide is an efficient activator of RNase H.
The presence of one or two mismatched nucleotides in the phosphodiester portion
of oligonucleotides affected this activation only negligibly. When introduced
into
tax
-transformed fibroblasts
ex vivo
, only the uniformly modified anti-
tax
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotide caused a sequence-dependent reduction in the Tax protein level. Neither the chimeric
phosphoramidate nor the phosphorothioate oligodeoxynucleotides significantly
reduced
tax
expression under similar experimental conditions.
Antisense oligonucleotides are currenly widely used to interfere in a sequence-specific manner with gene expression (
1
). Several types of backbone modifications have been developed to improve
oligonucleotide stability against nucleases and to improve their affinity for
RNA. However, the type of oligonucleotide chemical modification affects the potential mechanism by which it modulates gene expression. In contrast to modifications such as methylphosphonate, 2'-
O
-alkyl- or peptide oligonucleotides (PNAs), phosphorothioate oligodeoxynucleotides activate endogenous RNase H (
2
). For this reason, phosphorothioate oligodeoxynucleotides are often the most
efficient type of antisense oligonucleotides (
3
,
4
). However, an increasing number of studies demonstrate non-specific effects of these compounds, presumably due to binding of cellular
proteins or due to activation of RNase H and consequent cleavage of the mRNA
sequences, which are only partially homologous (
5
-
9
). In addition, phosphorothioate oligonucleotides have relatively low affinity for RNA target sites (
2
).
Replacement of the 3'-oxygen by a nitrogen results in a N3' -> P5' phosphoramidate internucleoside linkage (
10
). Phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides hybridize to complementary DNA or RNA in a sequence-specific manner with a much higher affinity when compared with the
isosequential unmodified phosphodiester oligonucleotides (
11
). NMR studies show that despite the lack of a 2'-hydroxyl group, double helices formed between phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides adopt the A-type conformation (
12
). However, very limited information is available about their biological properties, such as intracellular stability, potential
activation of RNase H and antisense activity (
13
,
14
).
In the present study we examine the stability and gene inactivating potential of uniformly modified or chimeric phosphodiester-phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides. We show that phosphoramidate
internucleoside linkages confer a high degree of stability in the nuclear
extract environment. In addition, we demonstrate that phosphoramidate oligonucleotides do not activate cellular RNase H, but chimeric oligomers do. Despite this, a uniformly modified
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucletide was the only compound able to specifically
and selectively interfere with
tax
gene expression at low concentrations.
Oligonucleotide phosphoramidates were prepared as described (
15
). Cell nuclei were isolated from
tax
-transformed mouse fibroblasts as described (
16
). The susceptibility of oligonucleotides to degradation by nuclear suspensions
was examined by incubation in a reaction mixture (10 [mu]l final volume) containing 300 nM 5'-32
P-labeled oligonucleotide, 25 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 100 mM KCl, 10 mM MgCl2
and nuclei (8-12.5 [mu]g protein/[mu]l) at 37oC. Aliquots of 1 [mu]l were withdrawn at the indicated time points, added to
2 [mu]l stop mix (8 M urea, 50 mM EDTA, 0.05% bromphenol blue, 0.05% xylene
cyanol) and analyzed by denaturing 20% polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis,
followed by autoradiography.
Incubation of oligonucleotides with cell nuclei was performed in the presence of
25 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 100 mM KCl, 10 mM MgCl2
, nuclei (8-12.5 [mu]g protein/[mu]l) and 1 [mu]M oligonucleotide. After incubation for 1 h at 37oC, the RNA was isolated as described (
16
) and analyzed by the RNase protection assay followed by quantitation with a
Pharmacia LKB Ultrascan XL laser scanner.
RNase protection assays were performed as described (
16
). The 227 nt run-off transcript obtained with pGEM3tax served as the probe. The L32 mRNA
served as a loading control. Protected fragments were separated on a 5-10% polyacrylamide gel containing 8 M urea and analyzed by
autoradiography.
The fibroblastic B cell line derived from LTRtax transgenic C57BL/6 mice (
17
) was grown in DMEM supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum at 37oC and 5% CO2
. B cells were trypsinized and adjusted to 105
cells/ml. They were seeded into 24-well plates at 500 [mu]l/well and incubated overnight at 37oC, 5% CO2
and 95% humidity. The following day the medium was aspirated, the cells were
washed with serum-free DMEM (1 ml/well), followed by addition of 200 [mu]l/well serum-free DMEM containing 30 [mu]g/ml lipofectamine. After addition of 25 [mu]l 20 [mu]M oligonucleotide, the plate was incubated as above
for 5 h, followed by addition of 500 [mu]l complete medium. Protein was analyzed by immunoblotting after 16 h
incubation.
Sugar-phosphate backbone-modified oligonucleotides in general and phosphorothioate compounds
in particular exhibit superior resistance against nuclease degradation compared with unmodified phosphodiester oligomers (
1
). To examine the relative stabilities of the oligonucleotides in the nuclear compartment, 5'-32
P-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides were incubated in cell nuclei suspensions. For the unmodified oligonucleotide 1 (Table
1
) incubated in nuclear extract, no full-length product could be detected after 5 min, the time point when the
first aliquot was taken (Fig.
1
, lane PO 5'). This is in accord with our previously published results (
18
) and demonstrates the extremely low stability of unmodified phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotides under the test conditions. In contrast, compound 2,
(Table
1
), containing uniform phosphoramidate linkages, remained intact for at least 1 h
incubation in nuclei suspension (Fig.
1
, lanes NP). Similarly, the chimeric oligomer containing six central
phosphodiester linkages flanked by 3'- and 5'-terminal phosphoramidate linkages was not degraded
within 1 h incubation time (Fig.
1
, lanes NP-PO-NP). The two shorter bands visible in these lanes are also present
in the control lane, corresponding to starting material, and thus are not due
to degradation during the incubation in nuclei suspension. This finding
indicates that the main degrading activities in cell nuclei are exonucleases
which are blocked by terminal phosphoramidate linkages. Interestingly, for an
oligodeoxynucleotide containing exclusively phosphorothioate linkages (6, Table
1
), a ladder of shorter bands appeared during the 1 h incubation in nuclei
suspension. These shorter products have a relatively low intensity and suggest a slow degradation by at least 3'-exonucleases. This finding is not surprising, since several nucleases have a
preference for one phosphorothioate P-diastereomer over the other and can cleave the corresponding
phophorothioate linkage relatively efficiently (
19
). Since conventionally synthesized phosphorothioate oligonucleotides represent a racemic mixture, the bands may
represent oligonucleotides which contained one or more phosphorothioate
linkages in the cleavable configuration. Taken together, the results suggest an
at least similar stability of the phosphoramidate and phosphorothioates
oligonucleotides in cell nuclei extract. This does not represent differential susceptibility of the
phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotide to phosphatase, since we have demonstrated
approximately equal susceptibility of phosphodiester, phosphoramidate and phosphorothioate oligonucleotides to phosphatase (
13
,
18
). Further, these stabilizing modifications are not present on the 5'-ends.
Table 1
Phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides represent a new class of potential
antisense compounds with high affinity for complementary RNA and DNA oligomers
(
11
). In the present study we compared the stability of oligonucleotides containing
phosphoramidate linkages with those of unmodified or phosphorothioate
oligodeoxynucleotides in intact cell nuclei. Under such conditions, the
unmodified control oligodeoxynucleotide was degraded within 5 min incubation
(Fig.
1
). Similar to the phosphorothioate control, the corresponding phosphoramidate
oligodeoxynucleotide remained completely intact after up to 1 h incubation.
This shows that phosphoramidate internucleoside linkages confer high stability
against nucleases present in cell nuclei. An oligonucleotide containing five
consecutive phosphoramidate linkages at both the 5'- and the 3'-termini exhibited comparable stability, which points
to exonucleases as being the major oligonucleotide degrading activities in cell
nuclei. This conclusion is also supported by several other studies employing
oligonucleotides bearing terminal modifications such as phosphorothioate or
methylphosphonate linkages (
18
,
20
,
24
). Indeed, we have demonstrated 5' -> 3' exonuclease to be important in nuclei (
18
). In contrast, data obtained with oligonucleotides injected into mice suggest
that terminal phosphorothioate linkages are not sufficient to improve the
stability or, consequently, bioavailability of oligonucleotides
in vivo
(
22
). Similar studies remain to be performed for phosphoramidate oligonucleotides.
Heteroduplexes formed by phosphoramidate and RNA strands are apparently not
substrates for mouse nuclear RNase H. Similar results have been reported using
a bacterial enzyme (
14
). In this respect, phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides resemble compounds such as PNAs, methylphosphonates and 2'-
O
-alkyl oligonucleotides (
2
,
23
). However, an open question is whether the induction of RNase H by an antisense
oligonucleotide is necessary for efficient inhibition of gene expression or
whether binding of the oligonucleotide to its target sequence with high
affinity is sufficient to achieve this goal. Several previous studies support
the first assumption: oligonucleotides which could induce RNase H-mediated RNA degradation appeared much more potent inhibitors of gene
expression than those not able to support RNase H (
3
,
4
). This could be complicated by differences in affinity. Further, this poses a
dilemma for any exogenous antisense approach. On the one hand, from a
statistical point of view, oligonucleotides of at least 15 nt in length may
guarantee recognition of unique sites in the human mRNA pool but may have low
T
m
values. On the other hand, longer complementary sequences more easily tolerate
single mismatches, thereby most likely reducing the specificity of the
antisense oligonucleotide (
24
). Thus, an oligonucleotide which induces RNase H might cause degradation not
only of its specific target RNA but also of other RNAs containing related
sequence motifs (
25
,
26
).
One possible approach to solve this dilemma is the use of chimeric
oligonucleotides. A central sequence containing 2'-deoxynucleoside moieties linked by phosphodiester or
phosphorothioate linkages could be flanked by stretches of 2'-modified nucleoside moieties or, for example, methylphosphonate
linkages. In this case only the central part would induce RNase H, but not the
flanking sequences. Studies by Monia
et al
. suggest that a 5 nt central stretch is sufficient to induce RNase H
efficiently (
3
). Thus, one might expect that shortening the part relevant for RNase H
induction to 5 nt might result in increased specificity of RNase H induction.
Indeed, data obtained by Giles
et al
. (
21
) with chimeric anti-
bcr
-
abl
oligodeoxynucleotides containing five to nine central phosphodiester linkages
flanked by methylphosphonate linkages support this.
In the present study, we compared phosphodiester, phosphorothioate and chimeric
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides for their ability to elicit mammalian
RNase H. Like the former two oligodeoxynucleotides, the chimeric
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotide containing six central phosphodiester
linkages flanked by phosphoramidate linkages induced RNase H-mediated degradation of the endogenous
tax
transcript in cell nuclei suspension (Fig.
3
). In addition, chimeric phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides with central T-U or C-U plus T-U mismatches respectively still caused significant RNase H-mediated cleavage of
tax
RNA. In contrast, a completely phosphorothioate modified oligodeoxynucleotide of the same mismatched sequence could not induce degradation of
tax
RNA, despite its longer `recognition surface' for RNase H. Whereas
phosphorothioate linkages decrease the affinity of an antisense oligodeoxynucleotide for its complementary RNA, phosphoramidate linkages increase the
T
m
of the heteroduplex by ~2oC per residue (
11
). Thus, the lower specificity of RNase H-mediated RNA degradation in the chimeric molecules may be due to the
superior stabilities of phosphoramidate-RNA duplexes compared with those of the phosphorothioate-RNA duplex. This implies that the amount of RNase H activation may
be dependent on the overall stability of the heteroduplex and not directly on
the number of RNase permissive Watson-Crick base pairs formed between oligonucleotide and target RNA. Similar results obtained with chimeric 2'-
O
-alkyl- and methylphosphonate oligonucleotides have recently been published by Larrouy
et al
. (
26
). Thus, activation of endogenous RNase H may be a poor choice for a mechanism
for specific reduction of gene expression by antisense oligonucleotides,
especially given its irreversible nature.
Finally, we compared the intracellular efficacy of RNase H-activating oligonucleotides with those of phosphoramidate
oligodeoxynucleotides unable to activate RNase H. The oligonucleotides were
introduced into
tax
-transformed fibroblasts with cationic lipids. At moderate concentrations
neither the phosphodiester, the phosphorothioate nor the chimeric
phosphodiester-phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides caused a significant reduction in
Tax protein (Fig.
4
). It is not clear whether this lack of function is caused by a low
intracellular stability and/or insufficient affinity of such oligonucleotides
for their target RNAs. Alternatively, the intracellular concentration of
phosphorothioate oligonucleotides able to bind to their target sequences may be
reduced by non-specific interactions with cellular proteins (
6
,
9
). Only the completely modified phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotide 2 (Table
1
) was shown to reduce the amount of Tax by 70-90% compared with cells treated with cationic lipids alone. Control
phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides containing similar purine-rich sequence motifs, such as GGGA or TGGG, had a <2-fold effect on Tax protein, suggesting a sequence-specific antisense effect by complementary phosphoramidate
oligodeoxynucleotides (Fig.
4
B). The mechanism of inhibition by phosphoramidates may be interference with RNA
editing, processing, transport or steric blockage of the translational
machinery (
2
).
The presented results show that antisense phosphoramidate oligodeoxynucleotides may mediate a potent RNase H-independent inhibition of gene expression. It also implies that RNase H-mediated RNA degradation may not be necessary for efficient
inhibition of gene expression by antisense oligonucleotides. High RNA affinity
conferred by a phosphoramidate oligonucleotide may be sufficient to effectively
interfere with gene expression. However, other properties of phosphoramdiate
oligonucleotides, such as decreased non-specific adsorption to proteins, may confer additional advantageous
properties (
13
).
We would like to thank David Lloyd, Lawrence DeDionisio and Annette Raible for
the synthesis of oligonucleotides used in this study and Xiao Xu for advice.
This work at Scripps Research Institute was supported by a fellowship from Lynx
Therapeutics.
*To whom correspondence should be addressed at: Nanogen, 10398 Pacific Center
Court, San Diego, CA 92121, USA. Tel: +1 619 546 7700;
Fax: +1 619 546 7717; Email: mnerenberg@nanogen.com
Number
Oligonucleotide
Type
1
5'-CCCTGGGAAGTGGGC-3'
TAXAS(PO)
2
5'-ccctgggaagtgggC-3'
TAXAS(NP)
3
5'-ccctGGGAAGtgggC-3'
TAXAS(NP-PO-NP)
4
5'-ccctGGGTAGtgggC-3'
TAXAS(NP-PO-NP)T
5
5'-ccctGGTTAGtgggC-3'
TAXAS(NP-PO-NP)TT
6
5'-
TAXAS(S)
7
5'-
TAXAS(S)T
8
5'-
TAXAS(S)TT
9
5'-atgggaaaatcccacA-3'
IL6[kappa]BAS(NP)
10
5'-tgtgggattttcccaT-3'
IL6[kappa]BS(NP)
REFERENCES
Return

