ABSTRACT
We have previously demonstrated that an exon splicing silencer (ESS) is present within human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)
tat
exon 2. This 20 nucleotide (nt) RNA element acts selectively to inhibit
splicing at the upstream 3
'
splice site (3
'
ss #3) flanking this exon. In this report, we have used
in vitro
splicing of mutated RNA substrates to determine the sequences necessary and
sufficient for the activity of the ESS. The activity of the ESS within
tat
exon 2 maps to a 10 nt core sequence CUAGACUAGA. This core sequence was
sufficient to inhibit splicing when inserted downstream from the 3
'
ss of the heterologous Rous sarcoma virus
src
gene. Mutagenesis of the interspersed purines in the polypyrimidine tract of
the
tat
exon2 3
'
ss to pyrimidines resulted in a significant increase in splicing efficiency
indicating that 3
'
ss#3 is suboptimal. The ESS acts to inhibit splicing at the optimized 3
'
splice sites of both the HIV-1
tat
and RSV
src
constructs but with a reduced efficiency compared to its effect on suboptimal 3
'
splice sites. The results indicate that both the ESS and a suboptimal 3
'
splice site act together to control splicing at the 3
'
splice site flanking
tat
exon 2.
Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) is a complex retrovirus (
1
). Its genome contains five 5' splice sites and >10 3' splice sites. During virus replication, the HIV-1 9.2 kb primary transcript is spliced to >40 different
singly and multiply spliced mRNA species (
2
-
6
). The singly spliced mRNAs encode Env, Vif, Vpr and Vpu whereas the multiply
spliced mRNAs encode Tat, Rev and Nef (
5
,
7
,
8
). The unspliced mRNA is used as message for Gag and Pol and is packaged into
virions. Successful retroviral replication requires that a balance of these
mRNAs be maintained. This is achieved by regulating both alternative splicing
and transport of mRNA species (
9
).
The splicing of HIV-1 pre-mRNA is dependent on the host splicing machinery. In metazoan cells,
this process involves the cleavage and joining of the 5' splice site and the 3' splice site (3'ss) by the spliceosome which is assembled through a series
of protein-protein and protein-RNA interactions (
10
,
11
). Retroviral replication requires that the single full-length primary RNA transcript be spliced inefficiently (
12
,
13
). A number of
cis
-acting elements within the HIV-1 pre-mRNA have been shown to regulate splicing. These include the
polypyrimidine tract and branch point of the 3'ss (
14
-
16
), exon splicing enhancer and silencers, and downstream 5' splice sites (
16
-
18
). During the early stage of HIV-1 replication, doubly spliced
tat
,
rev
and
nef
mRNAs are constitutively transported from the nucleus into the cytoplasm and
translated independently of the expression of any viral proteins. Tat and Rev
are both essential proteins for viral replication. Tat is an
trans
-activator which binds to the
cis
-acting element TAR and enhances the transcription of viral RNA (
19
-
21
). Unspliced and singly spliced HIV-1 RNAs are retained in the nucleus in the absence of the Rev protein.
After the accumulation of sufficient Rev protein, HIV-1 replication switches to the late stage in which the Rev protein binds to
the Rev response element (RRE) located in the
env
gene. This facilitates the nuclear to cytoplasmic transport and the expression
of singly and unspliced RNAs (
22
-
25
).
We and others have previously demonstrated that
tat
/rev
exon 3 splicing is regulated by a suboptimal 3' splice site as well as by an exon splicing enhancer (ESE) and splicing
silencer (ESS) within
tat
/rev
exon 3 (
18
,
26
). An ESS is also present within
tat
exon 2. This element acts selectively to inhibit splicing at the upstream 3' splice site flanking this
tat
exon. The ESS has been defined by linker-scanner mutagenesis to a 20 nucleotide (nt) RNA sequence spanning the C-terminal region of
vpr
and the N-terminal
tat
coding region. It has also been demonstrated that the ESS sequence in
tat
exon 2 functions as a splicing silencer when placed downstream of the
heterologous Rous sarcoma virus (RSV)
src
3' splice site. The addition of competitor RNA containing the ESS to a
splicing reaction with HIV-1 RNA substrates containing the ESS causes a specific relief of inhibition
at the upstream 3' splice site (
18
). This led us to propose that this element represents a binding site for a
negative-acting cellular factor present in HeLa cell nuclear extract that inhibits
splicing at an early step (
18
). The studies in this report were carried out to further define this putative
cellular factor binding site.
All mutations were made by PCR-mediated site-directed mutagenesis (
27
). The regions corresponding to the PCR products were sequenced to confirm that
no misincorporation mutations had occurred. pHS1-X has been described previously (
17
) and was used as the parent plasmid for all mutant HIV-1 minigene constructs. These include pESS4142, pESS4344, pESS4546,
pESS4748, pESS4950, pESS5152, pESS53554, pESS5556, pESS5758, pESS5960,
pESS4748+ESS5152, pTat3'C, p[Delta]ESS and pTat3'C+[Delta]ESS. p[Delta]ESS was previously named pHS-1[Delta]SRE (
17
). They were all linearized with
Hin
dIII at nt 6026 of pNL4-3 (GenBank accession no. M19921) and used as templates to synthesize RNA
substrates by
in vitro
transcription. pRSVWT has been described previously (
28
) and was used to make all the RSV-derived minigene constructs which include pECS, pECC, pECUS, pECUC, pECDS,
pECDC, pESSS, pESSC, pSrc3'C, pSrc3'C+ESSS and pSrc3'C+ESSC. pSrc3'C was previously called pRSAP-1 (
28
). All plasmids derived from pRSVWT were linearized with
Nae
I at nt 7169 of RSV Prague A and used to synthesize RNA substrates.
RNA substrates of pHS1-X and its derivatives were synthesized by
in vitro
transcription with T3 RNA polymerase. RNA substrates of pRSV7169 and its
derivatives were synthesized by
in vitro
transcription with SP6 RNA polymerase. HeLa cell nuclear extracts were prepared
and splicing reactions were performed as previously described (
17
,
29
,
30
). The products of the splicing reactions were separated on 4% 7 M urea-polyarylamide gels. At least three gels for each substrate were scanned
and quantitated using an AMBIS image analysis system (AMBIS, Inc., San Diego,
CA). The amounts of product were calculated on the basis of the uridine number
of the RNA species and expressed as splicing efficiency relative to the wild-type to correct for different splicing efficiencies obtained with
different HeLa nuclear extract preparations.
We have previously demonstrated that a 20 nt ESS element (from nt 5841 to 5860),
present within the
tat
exon 2 of the HIV-1 strain NL4-3, acts to selectively inhibit splicing at the upstream 3' splice site (3'ss #3) flanking this
tat
exon (
17
,
18
). To further characterize this ESS, we created 2 nt substitution mutations
shown in Figure
1
A to determine the importance of the individual bases within the element. The
RNA substrates containing the mutations were spliced
in vitro
using HeLa cell nuclear extracts. As can be seen in Figure
1
B and D, mutations within the central eight nucleotides (ESS4748, ESS4950,
ESS5152 and ESS5354) resulted in significant increases in splicing indicating
that these nucleotides were essential for the activity of the ESS. However, the
2-3-fold increases obtained with these 2 nt substutution mutations were
lower than the ~4-fold increase obtained when the entire ESS region was deleted (
17
,
18
; see Fig.
3
C, compare WT to [Delta]ESS). Therefore, we determined the effect of a double 2 nt mutation
ESS4748+ESS5152 (Fig.
1
A). As shown in Figure
1
C and D, the level of splicing of this mutant substrate was increased to a level
comparable to the ESS deletion mutant ([Delta]ESS). On the other hand, mutant substrates ESS4142, ESS4546, ESS5556,
ESS5758 and ESS5960 were spliced with efficiencies that were, within
experimental error, the same as wild-type. Based on these results together with our previously published data (
18
), we concluded that the activity of the ESS was contained within the core
sequence CUAGACUAGA (nt 5846-5855). Mutant substrate ESS4344 was spliced with a somewhat lower
efficiency than wild-type. This indicates that in the HIV-1 context the upstream flanking sequence may modulate the negative
activity of the core element.
Having localized the negative activity of the ESS element within
tat
exon 2 to a 10 nt core sequence, we next asked whether this core element was
sufficient to inhibit splicing when placed in a heterologous context and
whether there is an effect of the flanking sequences on the ESS activity of the
core element. To this end, a series of RSV
src
gene substrates were created containing the ESS core sequence and flanking
sequences downstream of the
src
3' splice site. The corresponding RNA substrates were spliced
in vitro
. As shown in Figure
2
A, four pairs of insertion mutations were constructed. One member of each pair
contained the sequence; the other contained the complement of this sequence in
which the purines were changed to their corresponding complementary pyrimidines
and vice versa. All the insertions were placed at the same distance relative to
the upstream
src
3' splice site as was the ESS in the HIV-1 context. Substrates ECS and ECC contained only the 10 nt core
sequence of the HIV-1 ESS. ECUS and ECUC contained the ESS core and its immediate upstream 5
nt sequence whereas ECDS and ECDC contained the ESS core plus its immediate
downstream 5 nt sequence. ESSS and ESSC contained the 20 nt long ESS or its
complement and served as controls. Splicing of RSV
src
substrates ECS, ECUS, ECDS and ESSS was only about half as efficient as wild-type or substrates containing the corresponding complementary sequences
(ESC, ECUC, ECDC and ESSC) (Fig.
2
B and C). These results indicate that the ESS core sequence CUAGACUAGA is
sufficient to inhibit splicing at the heterologous
src
3'ss and that the upstream and downstream flanking sequences do not
significantly affect the activity of the ESS.
The
tat
exon 2 3' splice site contains a weak polypyrimidine tract and a nonconsensus 3'ss sequence. To determine if the negative activity of the ESS
requires a suboptimal upstream 3'ss, we synthesized RNA substrates with a consensus polypyrimidine tract
and 3' splice site sequence and tested them in an
in vitro
splicing system
(Fig.
3
A). The effect of the improved 3'ss was first tested in the context of an intact downstream ESS element.
This substrate (Tat3'C) demonstrated a 3-fold increase in splicing efficiency compared to a substrate
containing the wild type 3' splice site which was spliced very inefficiently (Fig.
3
B and C). Thus, splicing at
tat
exon 2, in addition to the negative effect of the ESS, is regulated by the
presence of a weak 3' ss which is in agreement with a previous study (
15
). Substrate [Delta]ESS, in which heterologous linker sequence was inserted into the ESS
demonstrated a 4-fold increase in splicing efficiency at
tat
exon 2 3'ss compared to wild-type substrate (Fig.
3
B and C). To determine if the ESS element could act to inhibit splicing at the
consensus optimized splice site, we studied substrate Tat3'C+[Delta]ESS which has both the improved 3'ss mutation and the deleted ESS element. The splicing
efficiency of this substrate was increased an additional 2-fold at
tat
exon2 3'ss compared to the splicing efficiency of substrate Tat 3'C (Fig.
3
B and C). This significant increase in splicing at the improved
tat
3' splice site when the ESS element was deleted indicated that the ESS
element still had a negative effect on splicing when placed downstream of a
consensus 3'ss. However, the magnitude of the inhibition was less compared to a 4-fold effect observed for the wild-type substrate (compare WT to [Delta]ESS; Tat3'C to Tat3'C+[Delta]ESS). This demonstrated that the
negative control of the ESS element on the splicing efficiency of the
tat
exon 2 3'ss is not absolutely dependent on a weak 3'ss but that the regulatory control of the ESS element is more
efficient in the context of a weak 3'ss.
To further test the effect of the HIV-1
tat
exon 2 ESS on a consensus upstream 3' splice site, we inserted both the ESS and its corresponding
complementary sequence downstream of an optimized avian retrovirus RSV
src
3' splice site. The optimized
src
3'ss has a consensus branch point and consensus polypyrimidine tract (Fig.
4
A) (
31
). The distance of the ESS relative to
src
3'ss was identical to the distance from the
tat
3' splice site in the HIV-1
tat
exon 2 context. As previously reported, the polypyrimidine tract of
src
3'ss is suboptimal and the improved polypyrimidine tract resulted in 1.7-fold increase of
src
splicing compared to wild-type substrate (Fig.
4
B and C; compare Src3'C and wild type) (
28
). When the ESS was inserted downstream of the optimized
src
3'ss, the splicing efficiency at
src
3'ss was reduced to approximately wild-type level (Fig.
4
B and C; compare Src3'C+ESSS and Src3'C). However, if the ESS complementary sequence was inserted, the
splicing efficiency at
src
3'ss was increased to levels seen with the optimized substrate containing
no insertions (Fig.
4
B and C; compare Src3'C+ESSC and Src3'C). These results demonstrated that the ESS was still functional
when placed downstream of an optimized heterologous 3'ss. However, the magnitude of the effect was reduced compared to the
activity of the ESS in the context of a suboptimal 3' splice site.
We thank Drs Stanley Perlman and Richard Roller for critical evaluation of the
manuscript. This research was supported by PHS grant number AI36073 from the
National Institutes of Health.
REFERENCES
Return


