ABSTRACT
The catalytic subunit of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PKcs) is a member of a sub-family of phosphatidylinositol (PI) 3-kinases termed PIK-related kinases. A distinguishing feature of this sub-family is the presence of a conserved C-terminal region downstream of a PI 3-kinase domain. Mutants defective in DNA-PKcs are sensitive to ionising radiation and are unable to carry out V(D)J recombination. Irs-20 is a DNA-PKcs-defective cell line with milder [gamma]-ray sensitivity than two previously characterised mutants, V-3 and mouse scid cells. Here we show that the DNA-PKcs protein from irs-20 cells can bind to DNA but is unable to function as a protein kinase. To verify the defect in irs-20 cells and provide insight into the function and expression of DNA-PKcs in double-strand break repair and V(D)J recombination we introduced YACs encoding human and mouse DNA-PKcs into defective mutants and achieved complementation of the defective phenotypes. Furthermore, in irs-20 we identified a mutation in DNA-PKcs that causes substitution of a lysine for a glutamic acid in the fourth residue from the C-terminus. This represents a strong candidate for the inactivating mutation and provides supportive evidence that the extreme C-terminal motif is important for protein kinase activity.
DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) consists of the heterodimeric Ku protein, comprising subunits of 80 and 70 kDa, and a large catalytic component termed the catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs) (1,2). Ku serves as a DNA targetting component, specifically recognising double-stranded (ds) DNA ends and binding of DNA-PKcs to DNA-bound Ku triggers the kinase activity. DNA-PK has been shown to function in DNA double-strand break repair and V(D)J recombination (for reviews see 3,4). DNA-PKcs at 14 kb is one of the largest cDNAs known and is a member of a sub-family of phosphatidylinositol (PI) 3-kinases, termed PIK-related kinases (5). In common with other members of the PI 3-kinase superfamily, DNA-PKcs has a conserved kinase motif close to its C-terminus. PIK-related kinases, including DNA-PKcs, have, in addition, a highly conserved domain at their extreme C-terminus (6-8). All members of this sub-family are large proteins and include the ATM protein, Schizosaccharomyces pombe rad3p and its homologues Mec1p, mei41, Tel1p, FRAP, Tor1p and Tor2p.
Radiation-sensitive mutants of cultured rodent cell lines have been categorised into complementation groups designated IR groups 1-10 (9,10). Members of three groups (4, 5 and 7) exhibit almost identical properties, including defects in DNA double-strand break rejoining and inability to carry out V(D)J recombination (11). The genes (XRCC5 and XRCC7) defined by two of these groups (5 and 7) encode components of DNA-PK (Ku80 and DNA-PKcs respectively) (12-16). Rodent mutants defective in Ku70 have not been identified in mutant hunts screening for radiosensitivity, but knock-out Ku70 embryonic stem cell lines have been constructed and display the anticipated ionising radiation sensitivity and V(D)J recombination defects (17). XRCC4, the gene defined by IR group 4, has also been cloned and recently shown to interact tightly with DNA ligase IV (18,19). The associated defect in V(D)J recombination in these mutants was surprising and is not a phenotype displayed by radio-sensitive mutants belonging to the other complementation groups. An early step during V(D)J recombination is formation of a site-specific double-strand break at the sub-exon segments that ultimately form the immunoglobulin and T cell receptor loci (for reviews see 20-22). The cell therefore appears to utilise the same machinery, which involves DNA-PK and the product of XRCC4, to repair radiation-induced double-strand breaks and enzyme-induced site-specific double-strand breaks introduced during development of the immune response.
A number of group 5 mutants (xrs 1-6, sxi 1 and 3, XRV-15B and XRV9B) have been isolated and the mutational change in XRCC5 (Ku80) has been identified for some of them (23-26). The mutations reported to date result in large deletions in Ku80 cDNA or lack of expression of Ku80 protein and have therefore not been informative for identification of important residues. All the Ku80 mutants lack both dsDNA end binding activity and detectable DNA-PK activity. They also lack Ku70 as well as Ku80 protein, indicating that co-association of the two Ku subunits is required for their stabilisation. Whilst studies involving site-directed mutagenesis are in progress to identify and investigate important domains within Ku70 and Ku80 (see for example 24,27), such an approach is proving difficult with DNA-PKcs due to its large size. An alternative and complementary approach is to characterise mutants defective in these proteins.
The scid cell line derived from the SCID mouse is a well-characterised group 7 mutant. Scid cells retain DNA end binding activity but lack detectable DNA-PK activity and have been shown to harbour a nonsense mutation in the C-terminus of DNA-PKcs resulting in a protein truncated by 83 amino acids (14-16,28-30). V-3, which is derived from the hamster CHO AA8 cell line represents another group 7 mutant. In this case no residual DNA-PKcs protein can be detected (14,16,31). Recently irs-20, a radio-sensitive mutant derived from another CHO cell line, CHO 10B2, has been shown to belong to the same complementation group (32-34). Irs-20 differs from V-3 and scid cells in showing less sensitivity to ionising radiation, indicating that it may retain some residual protein function. In this study we have characterised irs-20 at the biochemical level and have identified a mutational change in the C-terminus of DNA-PKcs. Our results suggest an explanation for the phenotype of irs-20 cells and provide supportive evidence that the highly conserved C-terminal region that lies downstream of the PI 3-kinase domain is required for kinase activity. To complement these studies YACs encoding human and mouse DNA-PKcs were introduced into irs-20 and V-3 cells and substantial complementation was achieved. The results provide evidence for further interactions between the components of DNA-PK and additional proteins.
Irs-20 was isolated from a mutagenised culture of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) 10B2 cells as described previously (32). V-3 and xrs-6 cells were derived from the CHO cell lines AA8 and CHO-K1 respectively (31,35). V-3 cells were a gift from Dr G.Whitmore. The scid cell line SCGR11 is an immortalised line derived from neonatal scid mice and was obtained from D.Weaver (36). Cells were cultured in minimal essential medium (Gibco) supplemented with non-essential amino acids and 10% fetal calf serum. Estimation of [gamma]-ray sensitivity was as described previously (32,37). A dose rate of 1.3 Gy/min was utilised for the high dose rate experiments. For the continuous exposure experiments (low dose rate) the dose rates utilised were from 3 to 12 cGy/h. V(D)J recombination assays were carried out as described previously (38,39)
Poly(A)+ RNA was extracted from 5 × 107 cells using a Quickprep Micro mRNA Purification Kit (Pharmacia Ltd). cDNA was synthesised from 0.5-1.0 µg poly(A)+ RNA using oligo(dT) primers and reverse transcriptase. For irs-20 sequencing, RT-PCR products were amplified using PfuI polymerase and primers A and HCS6, the products were cloned into pCR.22 and sequenced from single-stranded (ss)DNA using a Sequenase kit (Amersham Life Science Inc.).
PCR was carried out in 20 µl containing 2 µl 10× PCR buffer (500 mM KCl, 100 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.3, 15 mM MgCl2, 0.1% gelatin), 1.5 µl dNTPs (2.5 mM each dATP, dCTP, dGTP and dTTP), 2-5 pmol each oligonucleotide primer and 0.25 U Taq polymerase (HT Biotechnology Ltd). When necessary amplified products were separated on LMP agarose gels, excised and cleaned using the Wizard DNA Clean-up System (Promega Ltd) and cloned into a T vector (40). The annealing temperature was routinely 60°C, except for primer pairs HCS24/HCS20 and HCS6/MCS4, which were annealed at 68 and 65°C respectively. Primers utilised were (5' -> 3'): primer A, CACTTCACTTGAGTCTCTTCT; MCS4, GAAGAGACTCAAGTGAAGTGC; HCS6, CTGCTGTCAGTGAAGGTCTAGGAG; MCS2, GTCAGTCTCATGTTGCCAATG; MCS5, AGTTATAACAGCTGGGTTGGC; HCS20, ACCGAGGAGCCAGTGGCTGAT; HCS24, GGAGCTAATCGTACAGAAACAGTCACGGCT; HCS7, AAGAAAAAGTGATGCTGGAG; MCS6, GAGGAGCCAGTGGCTGATGCA; HCS4, GACTCAAAGCCACCTGGGAACCTG.
Aliquots of 8.5 µg total RNA were size separated by electrophoresis in 0.8% agarose-formaldehyde gels, transferred overnight to Hybond N (Amersham Life Science Inc.) in 20× SSC, baked at 80°C for 2 h and UV cross-linked. The probe was a 1.5 kb C-terminal fragment from hamster DNA-PKcs obtained by PCR amplification. The filters were also probed with full-length hamster Ku80 cDNA to verify levels of RNA loaded. The probes were labelled by random priming. Hybridisation was carried out under standard conditions.
EMSA experiments to measure DNA end binding activity were carried out essentially as described previously (1,12). In brief, extracts were prepared as described previously (41), incubated with [gamma]-32P-labelled ds oligo M1/M2 at room temperature for 30 min and DNA-protein complexes resolved on 4% polyacrylamide gels containing 5% glycerol. To examine DNA-PK activity DNA binding proteins were microfractionated using 80-100 µg whole cell extract and 5 mg DNA-cellulose beads. The microfractionated proteins were resuspended in Z'0.05 buffer and incubated with peptide and [[gamma]-32P]ATP (4000 µCi/mmol) in a final volume of 20 µl at 30°C for 10 min as described previously (42). The phosphorylated peptide was either precipated on Whatman P81 filter paper, washed and quantified by scintillation counting (Fig. 5B) or separated through 18% polyacrylamide gels using a Tris-tricine buffer system. Separation of the phosphorylated peptide from other proteins present in the extracts which might have become phosphorylated during the assay provides a more sensitive assay by reducing the background (see Fig. 2B). A peptide mutated for the DNA-PK consensus sequence was used as a control for the experiments in which the peptide was scintillation counted to detect any background labelling of other proteins.
Whole cell extracts were boiled in SDS-PAGE loading buffer and the proteins resolved by SDS-PAGE using 6 or 8% polyacrylamide for DNA-PKcs or Ku proteins respectively. The separated proteins were transferred to nitrocellulose membranes using a wet blotting apparatus, blocked for 1 h to overnight at 4°C with 5% skimmed milk solution and 0.05% Tween in PBS. The Ku antibodies utilised were Ku80-4 and Ku70-5, which were raised against Baculovirus-expressed Ku80 and Ku70 proteins respectively (Serotech, UK). The filters were developed using an enhanced chemiluminescence (ECL) kit (Amersham). The DNA-PKcs antibodies utilised were 42-27 and 18-2, hybridoma antibodies raised against purified human DNA-PKcs (43), FLA, raised against full-length human DNA-PKcs (44,45), and DNA-PKcs-3M, which was raised against the N-terminal region of mouse DNA-PKcs (this study). For 42-27 and 18-2 the secondary antibody was anti-mouse immunoglobulin and for the others anti-rabbit immunoglobulin antibody was utilised.
Library screening to identify human DNA-PKcs YAC 147 (29F, C4), derived from the ICI library, has been described previously (14). Two mouse YAC libraries (ICRF and Whitehead) were screened by PCR and hybridisation (46,47). YAC 155 is designated WIBRy910HO4186 and was shown to map to a single region of mouse chromosome 16 by in situ hybridisation.
Yeast cultures containingYACs were grown in SD medium containing adenine, tryptophan and tyrosine but lacking uracil according to Green and Olson (48). The dominant selectable marker, the neoR gene, was introduced into YACs by a retrofitting technique as described (49) and retrofitted YACs were grown in medium containing uracil, tryptophan and tyrosine but lacking adenine. The sizes of YACs were estimated before and after retrofitting by pulse field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) using a Waltzer Apparatus (50). YACS were transferred to mammalian cells by a protoplast fusion technique as described previously (14).
Expression of DNA-PKcs transcript and protein in irs-20 and parental CHO 10B2 cells was examined by northern and western blot analysis (Fig. 1A and B). The level of DNA-PKcs mRNA was a few fold decreased in irs-20 compared with CHO 10B2. Scid fibroblasts also have slightly decreased DNA-PKcs transcript levels, but V-3 cells have very considerably reduced, although detectable, DNA-PKcs mRNA (29). DNA-PKcs protein expression was examined by western immunoblotting using three anti-human DNA-PKcs antibodies, FLA, 42-27 and 18-2, and an anti-mouse DNA-PKcs antibody, DNA-PKcs-3M, using whole cell extracts from irs-20 and wild-type hamster cells. In all cases a residual level of cross-reacting protein was detectable in irs-20 extracts, which represents ~10% of the DNA-PKcs level present in wild-type cells (shown in Fig. 1B using antibody 18-2). The decreased DNA-PKcs protein levels in irs-20, which are more marked than the decrease in transcription level, may arise as a result of decreased transcript expression or stability as well as decreased protein stability. Extracts of V-3 and scid fibroblasts were also examined for DNA-PKcs expression using the same antibody for comparison with irs-20 (Fig. 1B). In line with previous observations, V-3 cells lack detectable DNA-PKcs protein but scid fibroblasts have just detectable DNA-PKcs levels that are considerably lower than that seen in irs-20 extracts (14,16,51). In these western analyses we, like others, have also observed a strongly cross-reacting p220 protein in rodent extracts (28). Since this band is present in V-3 cells, which have very low DNA-PKcs transcript levels, it is unlikely to be a DNA-PKcs breakdown product and may represent a DNA-PKcs-related protein, possibly another member of the PI 3-kinase family. Interestingly, we have observed this band to be present at variable levels in extracts of wild-type cells but consistently present at high levels in extracts of all DNA-PKcs-defective cells.
The presence of DNA-PKcs protein in irs-20 cells permitted an examination of its ability to bind to DNA. dsDNA-cellulose beads were mixed with whole cell extracts from irs-20 and CHO 10B2 cells and the microfractionated DNA-bound proteins were detached by boiling and analysed by immunoblotting using antibody 18-2. Figure 2A shows that, surprisingly, equal levels of DNA-bound DNA-PKcs were recovered from whole cell extracts of irs-20 and CHO 10B2, even though the DNA-PKcs level present in whole cell extracts of irs-20 cells was 10-fold lower than that seen in CHO 10B2 cells (Fig. 1B). The level of DNA-bound DNA-PKcs recovered from irs-20 cells compared with CHO 10B2 cells varied considerably between experiments but was consistently greater than the 10% parental level seen with whole cell extracts. The amount of DNA substrate available was not rate limiting in these experiments. Notwithstanding these differences, these results show that DNA-PKcs in irs-20 cells retains the ability to interact with DNA in the presence of Ku.
The ability to recover DNA-PKcs from DNA-cellulose beads enabled us to assess whether the mutant irs-20 protein also retained DNA-PK activity. We therefore assayed the DNA-bound DNA-PKcs from CHO 10B2 and irs-20 cells for DNA-PK activity using the same extracts used to assess DNA-PKcs protein levels in Figure 2A (Fig. 2B). Although CHO 10B2 had significant levels of DNA-PK activity, no activity could be detected in extracts from irs-20cells.
To verify the presence of a functional binding component of DNA-PK the dsDNA end binding activity of Ku was examined by EMSA using crude whole cell extracts of irs-20, xrs-6 and wild-type hamster cells. As expected, irs-20cells, like scid and V-3 cells, were found to have wild-type levels of end binding activity (data not shown).
Taken together, these results confirm the conclusions based on cell fusion analysis that irs-20 belongs to group 7 and, like its fellow mutants, is defective in DNA-PKcs activity. In addition, and more significantly, these results show that the mutant irs-20 protein retains the ability to bind DNA in the presence of Ku but is unable to function as a protein kinase.
Previously we and others have identified a T -> Amutational change which gives rise to an ochre stop codon at amino acid 4045 in the extreme 3'-region of XRCC7 cDNA. We therefore examined this region of irs-20 XRCC7 (DNA-PKcs) by RT-PCR using primers MCS4 and HCS6 followed by cloning and sequence analysis of the products. Notably, we identified a G -> A mutational change in irs-20 cells at codon 4120 (the fourth residue from the C-terminus) that results in substitution of a lysine for a glutamic acid residue at this site. Since none of the clones derived from irs-20 (17 clones sequenced) contained the wild-type sequence we conclude that only the mutated allele is expressed. The mutational change destroys a NlaIV restriction site present in the wild-type sequence, thereby allowing the presence of the mutation to be examined in genomic DNA. Primers MCS4 and HCS6 were used to amplify a 156 bp fragment encompassing the mutated site from irs-20 and CHO 10B2 genomic DNA. The product was digested with NlaIV as well as FokI, a restriction enzyme used as a control since its restriction site is close to the NlaIV site but is not affected by the mutational change. The product derived from CHO 10B2 cells was completely digested by NlaIV yielding the two similarly sized products expected. The product from irs-20 gave a band the same size as the undigested PCR product in addition to the two smaller bands seen with CHO 10B2 (Fig. 3). Digestion with FokI yielded the two bands expected from both cell lines. Our results are consistent with the presence of the mutation in one allele of irs-20 genomic DNA and a wild-type sequence in the second allele. Only the allele with a mutational change in the C-terminal region of DNA-PKcs is expressed.
Figure
In addition, we observed that some of the clones sequenced had an insertion of 70 bp at codon 3858. Amplification and sequencing of this region from genomic DNA using primers HCS20 and HCS24 revealed that the inserted sequences were derived from a small intron. This region was amplified by RT-PCR from irs-20, CHO 10B2, CHO K1, xrs-6 and V-3 cells and the products analysed by electrophoresis. In all cases the dominant product was of the size expected from the cDNA sequence (174 bp), but a weaker larger band of the size expected for retention of the intron (244 bp), representing ~10% of the RT-PCR products, was also detected (data not shown). The genomic DNA representing the original RT-PCR product amplified encompassed 6 introns but the only one retained was the small one identified, making it unlikely that our cDNA was contaminated with a low level of genomic DNA. We conclude that a 70 bp intron is retained in a small percentage of cDNAs in wild-type and irs-20 cells. Although this aberrant splicing event may be of functional significance, it appears to be unrelated to the irs-20 mutation.
YACs encoding human DNA-PKcs partially complement the radiosensitivity of V-3 cells, but give full correction of the defect in V(D)J recombination (14). To verify that irs-20cells are defective in DNA-PKcs and to establish whether the partial complementation is a feature common to other group 7 mutants we introduced the retrofitted YAC encoding human DNA-PKcs (YAC 147) into irs-20 cells by protoplast fusion. Four out of seven independent G418R (the selectable marker present on the retrofitted YAC) clones obtained showed significant correction of the [gamma]-ray sensitivity characteristic of irs-20 cells using our standard high dose rate irradiation procedure (Fig. 4A). irs-20 cells are reproducibly less sensitive than V-3 cells by this procedure, but exhibit more dramatic sensitivity when survival is examined under continuous low dose rate exposure conditions. Two representative clones were therefore examined under these conditions and although significant correction was observed, wild-type levels of resistance were not achieved (Fig. 4B).
V(D)J recombination was also investigated in irs-20 and in these two clones. irs-20 cells show a dramatic decrease in the frequency of coding joint formation and a modest decrease in signal joint formation, similar to that observed with scid and V-3 cells (34). Here we also sequenced the junctions formed and found, curiously, that both types of joints recovered from irs-20 displayed smaller deletions than those recovered from the other group 7 mutants (data not shown; 38,39,52). In addition, there was an absence of abnormally long p nucleotides, another characteristic feature of coding joins recovered from scid and V-3 cells lines (data not shown). In line with our previous results with V-3 YAC fusion hybrids, the two irs-20 YAC fusion clones were fully complemented for the frequency and fidelity of V(D)J recombination (Table 1). Excluding some minor differences in junctional accuracy at signal junctions (Table 1), the irs-20 YAC fusion hybrids, like the V-3 hybrids expressing human DNA-PKcs, regain the ability to carry out V(D)J recombination to parental levels and with parental fidelity, although only partial correction of the [gamma]-ray sensitivity is achieved.
Group 5 (Ku80) defective rodent mutants are also only partially complemented by human Ku80 cDNA, but full complementation can be achieved using hamster Ku80 cDNA. We therefore tested whether full complementation could be achieved by introducing YACs encompassing the mouse gene for DNA-PKcs, since hamster YAC libraries are not available. The ICRF and Whitehead mouse YAC libraries were screened by hybridisation using a mouse DNA-PKcs cDNA clone and by PCR using primers specific for the 3'-UTR region of the mouse DNA-PKcs gene. Several YACs were obtained and analysed for integrity of DNA-PKcs by Southern hybridisation using cDNA probes to the 5'- and 3'-regions of the genes. By these criteria one YAC (YAC 155) appeared to carry the gene intact and, following retrofitting, was transferred to V-3 and irs-20cells. Six G418R clones from each fusion were analysed for radiation sensitivity and gave significant rescue of the radiosensitive phenotype of the parental cells (results for a representative clone are shown in Fig. 4A). For irs-20hybrids survival was close to the level observed in wild-type cells, although when survival was analysed using the more sensitive continuous exposure assay the hybrids appeared slightly more sensitive than the parent strain and similar in resistance to that observed with the human YACs (Fig. 4B). The V-3 hybrids were also clearly only partially complemented and had survival levels similar to the hybrids expressing human DNA-PKcs (Fig. 4A). Two representative clones from each fusion were shown to carry out V(D)J recombination at frequencies equal to or even greater than those observed in wild-type hamster lines (Table 1). Analysis of the junctions revealed that neither the signal nor coding junctions could be distinguished from those seen in parental cells.
Cell extracts from the V-3 and irs-20hybrids containing YAC 147 and YAC 155 were examined for levels of DNA-PKcs protein by western blotting using the anti-DNA-PKcs antibody 18-2 (Fig. 5A). irs-20 and V-3 hybrids containing YAC 147 (human DNA-PKcs) expressed levels of DNA-PKcs protein greater than that observed in parental cells and within the range of that observed with human cell extracts, whilst the hybrids containing YAC 155 (mouse DNA-PKcs) express DNA-PKcs protein at comparable levels to the parental rodent cells. Although the levels of DNA-PKcs expressed in the YAC 155 versus YAC 147 hybrids cannot be compared directly, since the antibody may not cross-react equally with the human and rodent proteins, these results suggest strongly that expression of DNA-PKcs from the YAC in the hamster background relates to that of DNA-PKcs from the species from which the YAC was derived.
Cell extracts from the hybrids and parent strains were also examined for DNA-PK activity (Fig. 5B). The levels of kinase activity approximately reflected DNA-PKcs protein expression levels. Thus hybrids expressing human DNA-PKcs had levels of kinase activity approaching the levels seen in human cells and the hybrids expressing mouse DNA-PKcs had levels comparable with that seen in rodent cells (Fig. 5B). These results verify that the radiosensitivity, V(D)J recombination and DNA-PK defects identified in irs-20cells can be corrected by YACs encoding DNA-PKcs.
Table 1. Table 2.
We have characterised at the molecular and biochemical level the defect in the IR group 7 mutant irs-20. The phenotypes of irs-20 and three other DNA-PKcs-defective cell lines are summarised in Table 2. Like the other mutants, irs-20 has wild-type levels of dsDNA end binding activity but no measureable DNA-PK activity. However, in other properties the irs-20 mutation produces a less severe phenotype, including a milder [gamma]-ray sensitivity and V(D)J recombination defect. Compared with V-3 and mouse scid cells, irs-20 retains higher residual levels of DNA-PKcs protein, which is able to bind to DNA but is unable to function as a protein kinase, consistent with similiar observations reported by Peterson et al. (53). Although, whole cell extracts from irs-20 cells had reduced levels of DNA-PKcs compared with wild-type cells, surprisingly, similiar levels were recovered from DNA-cellulose beads. One explanation is that a signficant percentage of DNA-PKcs from wild-type cells is or can become autophosphorylated, which decreases its DNA binding (54). The ablated kinase activity of irs-20 DNA-PKcs precludes autophosphorylation, which might lead to an elevated percentage of DNA-PKcs able to bind to the DNA cellulose. DNA-PKcs from irs-20 cells resembles that from scid cells. Scid lymphocytes and fibroblasts have decreased levels of DNA-PKcs protein which is able to bind DNA (28). Unfortunately, it was not possible to conclude whether the lack of kinase activity in these cell lines resulted from decreased protein levels or non-functional protein. However, a pre-B scid cell line has been described which is unable to carry out V(D)J recombination but retains wild-type levels of scid DNA-PKcs protein. Significantly, though wild-type levels of DNA-PKcs are retained, the pre-B scid cell line lacks DNA-PK activity (55). Therefore, it appears that the DNA-PKcs present in scid cells, like that in irs-20 cells, retains the ability to bind to DNA but cannot function as a protein kinase. Taken together, therefore, there is a striking similarity between the mutant DNA-PKcs protein from mouse scid and irs-20 cells.
We also show here that although irs-20 has two genomic DNA copies of DNA-PKcs, the only allele expressed has a G -> A base change resulting in substitution of a lysine for a glutamic acid as the fourth amino acid from the C-terminal end of the protein. DNA-PK belongs to the PIK-related sub-family of PI 3-kinases (6-8). The sub-family is characterised by a highly conserved motif at the extreme C-terminus, just downstream of the conserved PI 3-kinase domain. Significantly, the PIK-related kinases have protein rather than lipid kinase activity (5). The mutation identified in irs-20 lies within the highly conserved 3'-terminus but outside the conserved PI 3-kinase domain. The changed residue is conserved between human, mouse, hamster and equine DNA-PKcs, although interestingly a lysine residue is found at this site in the ATM protein, another member of the PIK-related sub-family (5,29,56). The substitution of a lysine for a glutamic acid results in change of an acidic to a basic amino acid. This is a significant change in charge and could severly affect the structure and activity of a protein. Sequence analysis of DNA-PKcs from mouse scid cells has shown that the only mutational change creates an ochre mutation and a protein truncated by 83 amino acids (28-30). Like the irs-20 mutation, this does not disrupt the PI 3-kinase domain per se. This mutational change appears to compromise stability of the protein and its ability to function as a protein kinase, but not its ability to interact with DNA-bound Ku.
Since we have sequenced only 1.3 kb of the 14 kb DNA-Pkcs cDNA from irs-20 cells, we are unable to conclude that the mutational change represents the only mutation. However, the milder phenotype of irs-20 compared with scid cells is consistent with the less severe mutational change observed, namely a single amino acid change rather than loss of 83 amino acids. Additionally, the striking similarity between the mutant scid and irs-20 proteins is consistent with the causal mutation occurring in a similiar region of the protein and the presence of full-length protein is in agreement with an inactivating missense mutation. Taken together, this makes the G -> A point mutation identified a likely candidate for the inactivating mutation in XRCC7 in irs-20 cells. If this is the causal mutation, then residue 4120 must be particularly important for kinase function. The milder phenotype of irs-20 cells may arise because there is a higher level of residual protein compared with scid and V-3 cells. The residual protein may retain some kinase activity, a possibility since the PI 3-kinase domain remains intact, or, alternatively, may play some other role in DNA double-strand break repair. An inactivating mutation has also been identified in the C-terminal region of both XRCC7 alleles in equine scid cells and in one allele of V-3 cells (see Table 2). The presence of mutations in the C-terminal region of all these mutants further supports the notion that this region of the protein is indispensible for DNA-PKcs function.
Our sequence analyses reveal that ~10% of cDNAs in all the hamster cell lines we examined retain a small intron. The inserted intron will almost certainly abolish the kinase activity, since it lies within the conserved kinase domain, contains a premature stop codon and renders the remaining cDNA sequence out-of-frame. Previously we have reported aberrant splicing of another intron in DNA-PKcs (29,57). One possibility is that these are forms of alternative splicing of some functional significance, possibly serving to control the level of kinase activity. It will therefore be of interest to determine whether the levels of these aberrant transcripts change after, for example, DNA damage or altered growth conditions.
The analysis of irs-20 and V-3 YAC fusion hybrids expressing human and mouse DNA-PKcs shows that DNA-PKcs expression and kinase activity levels are similar to the species from which the YAC was derived, demonstrating that expression levels are determined by sequences close to or within the DNA-PKcs gene. Additionally, high levels of kinase activity and cross-linking (data not shown) are achieved in the hybrids expressing human DNA-PKcs, showing that there is efficient interaction between the heterologous DNA-PK components. Despite this, the human DNA-PKcs gene did not fully complement the [gamma]-ray sensitivity of the two rodent mutants. Little additional complementation was achieved by introduction of the more closely related mouse DNA-PKcs (Fig. 4). Partial complementation of the radiosensitivity of V-3 cells was particularly surprising considering the full complementation for the V(D)J recombination phenotype and could be explained by the presence of a second mutation affecting radiation sensitivity but not V(D)J recombination. Alternatively, and more plausibly, neither the human nor mouse DNA-PKcs may be able to substitute fully for the hamster gene. The greater apparent complementation in irs-20 cells may simply result from the residual protein levels in these cells. We have previously reported that hamster DNA-PKcs is missing four amino acids within the 1.3 kb C-terminal region compared with the human and mouse proteins (29), which could affect protein conformation and protein-protein interactions. It is also notable that for both [gamma]-ray survival and V(D)J recombination the level of complementation does not parallel the level of kinase activity measured in the in vitro assay, providing further evidence that additional protein interactions are important. This could represent interactions with the in vivo phosphorylation substrate or additional protein interactions.
Despite the lack of full complementation when [gamma]-ray survival is the end-point analysed, the frequency of junctions formed during V(D)J recombination was restored to wild-type levels. Indeed, the frequency of recombination in hybrids containing mouse DNA-PKcs was greater than that obtained in wild-type hamster cells. This result therefore parallels the enhanced cross-linked DNA-PKcs protein seen in these hybrids and provides further evidence for differences between the mouse and hamster proteins as mentioned above. Elevated kinase levels are not seen in these hybrids however. Taken together, these results suggest that there are differences in the requirement of DNA-PKcs for DNA repair versus V(D)J recombination. Our results suggest that V(D)J recombination has a less stringent requirement for interactions involving DNA-PKcs, whereas optimal repair of [gamma]-ray induced double-strand breaks appears to require protein interactions which are not achieved optimally by the heterologous DNA-PK complex. In this context it has been suggested that DNA-PKcs may play a structural role in DNA repair.
In conclusion, we have identified a point mutation in a highly conserved domain of DNA-PKcs in irs-20 cells that represents a likely candidate for the causal inactivating mutation. The single residue changed lies outside the conserved PI 3-kinase domain, but in a region conserved between PIK-related kinases. Our results suggest that this region is required for DNA-PK activity but is not required for interaction of DNA-PKcs with DNA in the presence of Ku. It will therefore be of great interest to determine in greater detail the function of this region and how it modulates DNA-PK-dependent processes.
We thank Profs A.R.Lehmann and R.Corley for their invaluable support. Work in the S.P.J. and P.A.J. laboratories was supported by a collaborative grant from the Kay Kendall Leukaemia Fund. Additional work in the P.A.J. laboratory was funded by European Union grant F13PCT920007 and in the S.P.J. laboratory by grants SP2143/0101 and SP2143/0201 from the Cancer Research Campaign. G.E.T. is a special fellow of the Leukaemia Society of America and is partially supported by American Cancer Society grant IN97-T. Work in the J.S.B. laboratory is supported, in part, by grants CA09236, CA18023 and CA73926 from the National Cancer Institute, NIH, DHHS, USA.
Nucleic Acids Research
Pages
Introduction
Materials And Methods
Cell culture
cDNA synthesis and sequencing
PCR
Northern blot analysis
End binding and DNA-PK assays
Immunoblotting
YAC libraries screened
YAC growth conditions, retrofitting, pulse field gel analysis and transfer to mammalian cells
Results
Expression of the DNA-PK components in irs-20
DNA-PKcs from irs-20 cells is able to interact with DNA but lacks kinase activity
Sequence analysis of the 3'-terminal region of the DNA-PKcs cDNA from irs-20 cells
Complementation of irs-20 by YACs encoding human DNA-PKcs
Complementation of irs-20and V-3 cells by YACs encompassing mouse DNA-PKcs
Examination of hybrid YAC fusion clones
Discussion
Acknowledgements
References
Figure
Figure
Cell line
[gamma]-Raya
DNA-PK activityb
pJH200 (signal)
pJH290 (coding)
AmpRCamR/AmpR
Percentc
Relative parental level
Percent correct joinsd
AmpRCamR/AmpR
Percent
Relative parental level
CHO 10B2
R
+
65/2110
3.1
1
100
55/2450
2.0
1
Mock
R
+
-/6390
<0.015
<0.005
NA
-/4800
<0.02
<0.01
irs-20
S
-
60/16200
0.37
0.12
75
2/27300
0.07
0.03
irs-20 + 155e
R
+
82/668
12.3
4
100
141/1310
10.1
5.1
irs-20 + 147
R
++
56/6300
0.9
0.3
87
416/19200
2.2
1.1
V-3f
S
-
54/9750
0.5g
0.22g
47
5/17,100
0.03
0.013
V-3 + 155e
R
+
54/435
12
4
100
69/1845
3.8
1.9
V-3 + 147f
R
++
224/4260
5.3g
2.12g
100
93/2900
3.2
1.6
Property
Murine scid cell line
Irs-20 (hamster)
V-3 (hamster)
Equine SCIDcells
Radiosensitivitya
2 Gy
2.8 Gy
2 Gy
2.7 Gy
V(D)J recombination
Large decreased frequency of coding joins: larger deletions at the junctions. Modest impact on signal joins
Large decreased frequency of coding joins: smaller deletions. Modest impact on signal joins
Large decreased frequency of coding joins: larger deletions. Modest impact on signal joins
Defective signal and coding joins
DNA-PKcs levels
Just detectable(~1% parental levels)
10% parental levels
Undetectable
Possibly just detectable
Mutation
Premature termination at residue 4045
Base change at residue 4124
Premature termination at residue 4024 in 1 allele; no mutation in C-terminus in 2nd allele
Premature termination at residue 3160
Kinase activity
Undetectable; protein lacks kinase activity
Undetectable; protein lacks kinase activity
Undetectable. One allele likely to be non-functional; 2nd allele unknown
Undetectable. Likely to be non-functional
Ability of DNA-PKcs to bind DNA
Proficient
Proficient
No residual protein to assess
Not examined.
REFERENCES
This page is run by Oxford University Press, Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP, as part of the OUP Journals
Comments and feedback: www-admin{at}oup.co.uk
Last modification: 27 Mar 1998
Copyright© Oxford University Press, 1998.
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. L. Ruis, K. R. Fattah, and E. A. Hendrickson The Catalytic Subunit of DNA-Dependent Protein Kinase Regulates Proliferation, Telomere Length, and Genomic Stability in Human Somatic Cells Mol. Cell. Biol., October 15, 2008; 28(20): 6182 - 6195. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. A. Mordes, G. G. Glick, R. Zhao, and D. Cortez TopBP1 activates ATR through ATRIP and a PIKK regulatory domain Genes & Dev., June 1, 2008; 22(11): 1478 - 1489. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Sun, Y. Xu, K. Roy, and B. D. Price DNA Damage-Induced Acetylation of Lysine 3016 of ATM Activates ATM Kinase Activity Mol. Cell. Biol., December 15, 2007; 27(24): 8502 - 8509. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Morita, A. Yamashita, I. Kashima, K. Ogata, S. Ishiura, and S. Ohno Distant N- and C-terminal Domains Are Required for Intrinsic Kinase Activity of SMG-1, a Critical Component of Nonsense-mediated mRNA Decay J. Biol. Chem., March 16, 2007; 282(11): 7799 - 7808. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
X. Jiang, Y. Sun, S. Chen, K. Roy, and B. D. Price The FATC Domains of PIKK Proteins Are Functionally Equivalent and Participate in the Tip60-dependent Activation of DNA-PKcs and ATM J. Biol. Chem., June 9, 2006; 281(23): 15741 - 15746. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Peng, R. G. Woods, H. Beamish, R. Ye, S. P. Lees-Miller, M. F. Lavin, and J. S. Bedford Deficiency in the Catalytic Subunit of DNA-Dependent Protein Kinase Causes Down-Regulation of ATM Cancer Res., March 1, 2005; 65(5): 1670 - 1677. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Rothkamm, I. Kruger, L. H. Thompson, and M. Lobrich Pathways of DNA Double-Strand Break Repair during the Mammalian Cell Cycle Mol. Cell. Biol., August 15, 2003; 23(16): 5706 - 5715. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Woods, W. Wang, E. Convery, A. Errami, M. Z. Zdzienicka, and K. Meek A single amino acid substitution in DNA-PKcs explains the novel phenotype of the CHO mutant, XR-C2 Nucleic Acids Res., December 1, 2002; 30(23): 5120 - 5128. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. K. Mauldin, R. C. Getts, W. Liu, and T. D. Stamato DNA-PK-dependent binding of DNA ends to plasmids containing nuclear matrix attachment region DNA sequences: evidence for assembly of a repair complex Nucleic Acids Res., September 15, 2002; 30(18): 4075 - 4087. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Mondello, P. Rebuzzini, M. Dolzan, S. Edmonson, G. E. Taccioli, and E. Giulotto Increased Gene Amplification in Immortal Rodent Cells Deficient for the DNA-dependent Protein Kinase Catalytic Subunit Cancer Res., June 1, 2001; 61(11): 4520 - 4525. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Fukumura, R. Araki, A. Fujimori, Y. Tsutsumi, A. Kurimasa, G. C. Li, D. J. Chen, K. Tatsumi, and M. Abe Signal Joint Formation Is Also Impaired in DNA-Dependent Protein Kinase Catalytic Subunit Knockout Cells J. Immunol., October 1, 2000; 165(7): 3883 - 3889. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Okayasu, K. Suetomi, Y. Yu, A. Silver, J. S. Bedford, R. Cox, and R. L. Ullrich A Deficiency in DNA Repair and DNA-PKcs Expression in the Radiosensitive BALB/c Mouse Cancer Res., August 1, 2000; 60(16): 4342 - 4345. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
L. J. Kienker, E. K. Shin, and K. Meek Both V(D)J recombination and radioresistance require DNA-PK kinase activity, though minimal levels suffice for V(D)J recombination Nucleic Acids Res., |






