| Nucleic Acids Research | Pages |
Short unligated sticky ends enable the observation of circularised DNA by atomic force and electron microscopies
Introduction
Materials And Methods
DNA and restriction enzymes
Electrophoresis
Electron microscopy
Atomic force microscopy
Population analysis and data
Results
Dimerisation of DNA fragments having one sticky end and one blunt end
Circularisation of DNA fragments having two sticky ends
Oligomerisation of DNA fragments having two sticky ends
Role of electric charges, and magnesium and uranyl ions on sticky ends pairing
Discussion
Acknowledgements
References
Short unligated sticky ends enable the observation of circularised DNA by atomic force and electron microscopies
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
No doubt, the most common technique used to analyse DNA cut by restriction endonucleases is to perform an agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE) of the reaction products. Another way is a direct observation and analysis of the DNA population by electron microscopy (EM) or more recent atomic force microscopy (AFM). Observation under the microscope gives the opportunity to monitor the cutting reaction continuously. However, when the population exceeds five fragments, measurements or counting can become very tedious.
As we have already shown, analysis of local curvature (1) or positioning of proteins interacting with a DNA molecule (2) is facilitated when the DNA fragment has been oriented, after specific incorporation at one end of a biotinylated nucleotide, by a streptavidin-ferritin complex (3). Labelling with either 5 nm streptavidin-gold spheres (4) or a chimerical streptavidin-immunoglobulin G-binding domain of staphylococcal protein A (5) has been proposed for analysis of biotinylated DNA molecules by AFM. Streptavidin alone, with no additional marker, is clearly visible in AFM and can be used for end-labelling (6). In order to avoid this requirement and its possible drawbacks, we prepared the molecules to be analysed using the following procedure. The DNA fragment was built in such a way that it possesses one blunt end and one sticky end; such fragments are then ligated with Escherichia coli ligase, which is active only on sticky-ended DNA fragments. The reaction product is a palindromic molecule twice the size of the original fragment. Consequently, any characteristic, such as a protein-specific binding site or a particular pattern (for instance a higher local curvature) will be observed twice on this molecule, at symmetrical positions.
For this procedure we originally used a 560 base pair (bp) DNA fragment which was rendered blunt at one end by PvuII and sticky at the other by PstI. Before performing the ligase reaction, we checked this DNA fragment by EM and by AFM. Under EM this fragment appeared as a 560 bp fragment with a length of 0.187 µm. But, under AFM, this DNA is often observed as a fragment measuring twice that length. This unexpected result is studied in detail here as a function of sticky end composition and length.
Ligation of DNA ends has been thoroughly studied in procedures where the process is catalysed by ligases, as discovered first by Gellert (7), or by topoisomerases (for a review see 8). In the case of bringing together DNA ends, many physical studies have been carried out in which sticky ends are involved, and mathematical models of this phenomenon have been proposed (9-12). However, until now the process has been analysed mainly with the use of DNA ligases.
In many biochemical processes, restricted DNA fragments are studied in the presence of a divalent cation, mainly Mg2+. It has been also reported that Mg2+ stabilises nucleic acid structures such as three-way DNA junctions (13), DNA nicks (14), Z-DNA (15), RNA conformations (16,17) or ribozymes (18,19). Mg2+ ions also contribute to the winding of the DNA helix, as observed in supercoiled DNA molecules (20,21), and enhances DNA curvature (22,23).
We have examined the behaviour of terminal ends of DNA restriction fragments and have analysed the effect of divalent cations on a population of such fragments. A comparative study has been made using AFM, EM and AGE. Numerous studies have been made on the stability of base pairs, mostly with short DNA (24) or RNA fragments (25). In this last study on short RNA duplex formation, a melting temperature of 22.6°C has been calculated for the sequence CCGG at 0.1 mM nucleotide in 1 M NaCl but hybridisation of the same sequence present at the extremities of short oligonucleotides has been observed in polyacrylamide gel at room temperature (26).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
DNA and restriction enzymes
All DNA fragments were prepared according to the following procedure. Samples of (5-10 µg) plasmid pSP65 or pUC19 DNA (a gift of J.M.Saucier) were cut with the restriction enzyme of interest (New England Biolabs, Beverly, MA, USA) until completion as judged by EM observation. Proteinase K (Boehringer Mannheim, Meylan, France) at a final concentration of 20 µg/ml was added to the tubes, and incubation at 37°C was continued for 1 h. The samples were then loaded on a MonoQ column and fractionated according to size on a Smart system (Pharmacia Biotech, Uppsala, Sweden) with a NaCl gradient (0.7-0.85 M). The fractions of interest were pooled and precipitated with ethanol. The precipitated fragments were resuspended in Te buffer (10 mM Tris, pH 8, 0.1 mM EDTA).
Electrophoresis
Electrophoresis of the DNA fragments were performed on mini 1% agarose (SeaKem LE, FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, ME, USA) slab gels (GIBCO BRL Life Technologies, Cergy Pontoise, France) in TAE buffer (40 mM Tris base, 0.1 mM NaEDTA, 20 mM sodium acetate, 29.6 mM glacial acetic acid, pH 7.8) with or without MgCl2 (10 mM). pSP65 plasmid DNA with all three natural forms (I supercoiled, II circular relaxed and III linear) was added in one well as markers. Electrophoresis was run in the cold for 3-4 h at 4 V/cm. The gels were stained with SYBR Green I (Molecular Probes Europe BV, Leiden, The Netherlands) and photographed using a yellow filter on Polaroid 667 films.
Electron microscopy
DNA samples (7 µl; [sim]1 µg/ml) in Te buffer with or without 10 mM MgCl2 were spread onto pentylamine-activated carbon-coated grids, washed and stained with 2% (w/v) uranyl acetate solution in water and dried on filter paper (27). When necessary uranyl acetate was added to the sample at a final concentration of 24 µM (see text). Grids were observed by use of annular dark-field illumination mode with a Zeiss CEM-902 microscope (28). Images were recorded on Kodak electron image film (Eastman Kodak, Rochester, NY, USA) at a magnification of 50 000 or 85 000×.
Atomic force microscopy
Samples of DNA were generally prepared as described by Delain et al. (29) with some modifications. DNA ([sim]1 µg/ml) was diluted in 10 mM Tris, pH 7.4, 10 mM MgCl2. Five microliters were deposited onto a freshly cleaved mica (five different micas including ruby type were used with similar results). After 1 min the sample was rinsed with 2-3 drops of 0.2% (w/v) aqueous uranyl acetate, blotted with paper and dried. For experiments in which the possible role of uranyl salt was examined, thorium nitrate (0.0001%, w/v), an alternative to uranyl acetate for DNA spreading and staining (30), was used in place of uranyl acetate or in association with a very low concentration of it, as indicated. In some experiments we used the technique described by Rivetti et al. (31), in which DNA was diluted in 4 mM HEPES pH 7.5, 10 mM NaCl, 2 mM MgCl2, deposited onto ruby mica for 2 min and rinsed with 10 ml of water with a syringe through a needle, blotted and dried. Following this last technique, we changed the rinsing procedure by replacing water with 10 ml of 10 mM MgCl2 or by an uranyl acetate rinse as used in our own protocol. For the temperature experiments, mica, uranyl acetate, the DNA solution and micropipettes were prewarmed to 50, 60 or 70°C in an incubator for 20 min before sample preparation. Observations were performed with a NanoScope IIIa (Digital Instruments, Santa Barbara, CA, USA) in the Tapping® mode in air, using standard TESP silicon tips. Fields of 1-4 µm were scanned at a maximum frequency of 1.5 Hz. Images (512 × 512) were flattened and exported as TIFF files to Adobe PhotoShop 4.0 for document preparation.
Population analysis and data
NanoScope images were imported on a MacIntosh Performa 6400/180 using the public domain NIH Image 1.61 (written by Wayne Rasband at the US National Institute of Health). Images of DNA molecules were treated using dedicated macros written by us. First they were individually cleaned (with verification against the NanoScope original image), then skeletonised, and finally length was measured on 100-300 molecules. Globally, our measurement method underestimates length by [sim]1% for small fragments (<500 nm) to [sim]6% (length >1 µm) as compared to the theoretical values calculated with 0.34 nm/bp. After counting, population analysis results were expressed in three different ways. Firstly, as a percentage of circularised forms, including monomers, dimers or larger oligomers. Secondly, as a percentage of oligomers of all sizes, either linear or circular. Lastly, as a percentage of paired sticky ends, which represents the whole reassociation of complementary sticky ends of the fragments, whatever the resulting form.
RESULTS
Table 1 summarises the results obtained in AFM for the DNA fragments, as a function of the sticky ends employed. In this table the samples preparation for AFM observation was always done according to our method including the uranyl acetate rinse.
Table 1
Influence of the GC content. First, we analysed the influence of the GC content of the sticky end on the dimerisation of DNA fragments having one sticky end and one blunt end. The following DNA fragments: PvuII (blunt)-EcoRI (0% GC), PvuII (blunt)-SphI (50% GC) and PvuII (blunt)-NgoMI (100% GC) were used for this analysis. Dimerisation was observed in all cases (Fig. When the two ends of the fragments are sticky and complementary, circularisation was observed in almost all cases. It was also seen when the two ends of the fragment are sticky and not complementary; but in this case oligomer formation takes place in order to allow cyclisation of paired oligomers giving rise to large circles (Fig. pSP65 DNA was cut with single cut restriction enzymes giving 4 nt sticky ends of different GC percentage in fragments of the same size (3005 bp). An analysis of the molecular population cut at the unique NgoMI site (100% GC) shows that 95% of the molecules are circularised and 87% are monomer circles (Fig. pSP65 DNA was then cut with the restriction enzyme ApaLI (50% GC), which forms three fragments (497, 1246 and 1262 bp), but only two populations distinguishable because the two large fragments differ only by 1% in length. In this case, a large percentage of circles is still observed: 82% for the small fragment and 87% for the large ones (Fig. Figure 1. Atomic force microscopy images of pSP65 DNA fragments deposited onto mica, appearing as linear or circular monomers, dimers or higher oligomers. (A) EcoRI 3005 bp fragment. (B) ApaLI 497 and 1246-1262 bp fragments (not distinguishable after measurements). (C) NgoMI 3005 bp fragment. (D) PvuII-NgoMI small fragment (511 bp). (E) PvuII-SphI large fragment (2333 bp). (F) Psp1406I mixture of small and large fragments (373 and 2632 bp). Abbreviations used to outline particular features: (m) monomer, (sm) small monomer, (lm) large monomer,(d) dimer, (o) oligomer; as last letter:(l) linear, (c) circular; Bar, 0.25 µm. DNA fragments having two sticky ends can also attach to another one. When the pSP65 plasmid was cut with NgoMI (100% GC content) 11% of the molecules were found to form linear or circular oligomers (Fig. Since circularisation or oligomerisation of sticky ends were not noticed previously by conventional EM or AFM, we further consider what could be the reason of this discrepancy. We looked particularly for the role of electric charges, and of magnesium and uranyl ions in sticky ends pairing. In EM, the carbon film is charged in the presence of pentylamine (27) to attach and spread the DNA; and after adsorption the DNA is washed with an aqueous uranyl acetate solution. In AFM, we also washed the sample with uranyl acetate; this is not commonly used, except in one published work on [Phi]X-174 single-stranded DNA (32). We performed EM and AFM experiments to study the effect of cations, and tried also to demonstrate reassociated DNA molecules by AGE.
Dimerisation of DNA fragments having one sticky end and one blunt end
Circularisation of DNA fragments having two sticky ends
Oligomerisation of DNA fragments having two sticky ends
Role of electric charges, and magnesium and uranyl ions on sticky ends pairing
Figure 2. Electron microscopy dark-field images of pSP65 DNA fragment (3005 bp). (A) Fragment cut by NgoMI in Te buffer as in usual EM preparation (without MgCl2 or CaCl2). (B) Same fragment as (A) but in Te buffer containing 23 µM uranyl acetate plus 10 mM CaCl2. (C and D) Fragment cut by AatII in the same buffer as (B) but with 10 mM MgCl2 instead of CaCl2 (the arrows mark the disruption of some DNA circles). (A-C) Magnification Bar, 0.1 µm.Atomic force microscopy. In an AFM experiment, the uranyl acetate concentration used for rinsing was lowered until only partial spreading of NgoMI cut DNA was observed (0.0002%, 4.7 µM). If we then add thorium nitrate (final concentration 1.7 µM), which is another DNA staining and spreading agent used for EM (30), to this low concentration of uranyl acetate, then circles are clearly observed, but in lesser amount probably related to the decrease of the UO22+ concentration. Thorium alone, at the same concentration, did not result in the detection of any circular molecules. AFM experiments were also done at lower Mg2+ concentrations; at 5 and 2 mM MgCl2 there was no difference in the observed populations. At lower concentrations, DNA does not attach homogeneously to the mica.
DISCUSSION
From the above results, we conclude that the divalent cation Mg2+ (or Ca2+) keeps together the sticky ends of the restricted fragments giving rise to their circularisation or their oligomerisation. Such a phenomenon was clearly observed under AFM when the material deposited onto the mica was washed with aqueous uranyl acetate. The occurrence of dimer formation through a four dG·dC base pair overhang has been observed in XmaI DNA fragments by polyacrylamide gels (26). But to our knowledge, circularisation or oligomerisation of DNA restriction fragments has not been visualized before by EM or AFM. Such sticky-ended DNA fragments have been used in the presence of Mg2+ ions in many AFM experiments (31-35). In our hands, using the conditions of Rivetti et al. (31), we also did not observe any interactions between DNA sticky ends, except when the final rinse of the sample was performed with uranyl acetate instead of water.
Figure 3. Agarose gel electrophoresis of pSP65 DNA cut by different restriction enzymes and run in the presence of 10 mM MgCl2. Lane A, NgoMI fragment (3005 bp). Lane B, EcoRI fragment (3005 bp). Lane C, AatII fragment (3005 bp). Lane D, Psp1406I fragments (373 and 2632 bp). Lane E, untreated DNA (3005 bp) showing a mixed population of superhelical, relaxed and linear molecules (forms I, II and III, respectively). The fragments size and the plasmid DNA forms are indicated on the left or on the right side, respectively. In agarose gel, when Mg2+ ions are present, the smears observed can be interpreted as an indication that the pre-existing structures in the presence of Mg2+, are partly destabilised during the migration. In EM, the carbon-coated grids are commonly charged in the presence of pentylamine (27), and the presence of positive charges on the grid could destabilise the sticky ends. During the deposition process there is adsorption to the grid at a given number of points along the DNA, followed by structural rearrangement of the molecule. The involved forces are probably stronger than the hydrogen bonding of the sticky ends. Moreover, after adsorption of the DNA sample onto the carbon film, the sample is commonly washed with an aqueous uranyl acetate solution. Consequently, one observes the precipitates of uranium atoms as clusters on the phosphate backbone (30). In AFM, under our own conditions, we also washed the sample with uranyl acetate. Thus, it appears that divalent ions such as magnesium and uranyl could play a role in sticky ends base pairs stabilisation. Under EM, using the glow-discharge method (27), uranyl acetate at a very low concentration must be added to the sample before deposit in order to reveal the presence of circularised or oligomerised molecules. Our hypothesis is that the large clusters of 10-20 uranium atoms (30) may reinforce the structures which have already been stabilised by the Mg2+ ion, possibly by binding to more distant negative phosphate sites of both strands. This property is not shared by the monovalent thorium nitrate salt. The concentration of DNA fragments, or of sticky ends, is an important factor in the annealing of the molecules. For instance, at high concentrations, as in a DNA stock solution at [sim]100 µg/ml, reassociation between sticky ends of different molecules is favoured, giving rise to oligomers. DNA samples are usually dissolved and analysed in buffers containing EDTA. We observed that if a stock solution containing MgCl2 is diluted in a buffer containing Mg2+, larger sized oligomers (linear tetramers and over) are seen as opposed to a stock solution with no MgCl2 and with 10 mM EDTA, even if the percentage of circularised monomers is about the same. From this observation, we can conclude that reassociation is a rapid process, since it occurred during the 5 min needed to dilute and prepare the AFM sample. Another important factor is the size of the fragments, as observed during the dimerisation of small fragments. The very short (226 bp) PvuII-EcoRI (0% GC content) fragments dimerised more efficiently than the longer (511 bp) PvuII-NgoMI (100% GC content) fragment. A third important parameter affecting the base pairing of sticky ends belonging to DNA fragment of given size, is their base composition and, notably their GC-content. The data presented indicate that in the presence of the divalent Mg2+ or Ca2+ ions, annealing of the sticky ends is extremely efficient when they are 100% GC as with NgoMI (4 nt sticky ends). Consequently, one might expect that association of independent molecules is not favoured in this case, and that circularisation of molecules is highly probable. Even with 2 nt GC-sticky ends (Psp1406I) reassociation is frequent, giving rise to oligomers and circles. In contrast, 2 nt AT-sticky ends, as shown with NdeI, are very unstable, which indicates that association rarely occurs with such molecules. The most favourable conditions for observing shuffling of DNA fragments to form combined species is thus 4 nt sticky ends with a 50% GC- or a 100% AT-content. When fragments having identical 100% GC-sticky ends are put in the presence of ligase, ligating them into circles should be very efficient, since 95% of the fragments are already circularised, as shown here, before the addition of the ligase. In ligation experiments, joining of the sticky ends and base pairing prevail over the ligature step. Due to the high stability of sticky end pairing we detect, one should always take into account the key role of the divalent cation on the molecules in biochemical processes; for instance, in the joining of EcoRI DNA fragments by the protein Ku (35) or, in recombination experiments with RecA, in which the observation of chiasma is probably not only due to the high efficiency of polymerisation of RecA but also to the high tendency of oligomerisation of the DNA fragments with sticky ends used (17,36-38). As a consequence, differences in the recombination process may occur depending the nature of the ends of the DNA fragments. The phenomenon described here provides a new tool for studying DNA. Firstly, the use of magnesium-stabilised inverted symmetrical dimers (in place of enzymatically ligated ones) permits the local curvature analysis of a selected DNA fragment without the need for end-labelling (A.Fourcade and B.Révet, in preparation). Such dimers also offer the possibility of discriminating between non-specific binding sites and specific ones by the symmetrical localisation of the ligand. Secondly, the pairing between sticky ends of the same DNA fragment should be very helpful in circularisation or ligation experiments, since it allows the independent study of the recognition steps, without any enzymatic ligation. Lastly, subtle base pair interaction could be analysed on very short sticky ends which sequence contains normal or modified bases. The present work offers a new possibility of analysing base pair stability in short DNA sequences and could be extended to other methods by the use of synthetic oligomers with sticky ends permitting studies of hydrogen bonding, base pair stacking and charge neutralisation. It also allows the analysis of the first process which takes place in ligation experiments as the products concerned, circularised or oligomerised fragments, can be analysed before the enzymatic event. It finally shows the important role of Mg2+ in stabilisation of DNA terminal ends. We hope also that our observation will initiate a large number of questions and investigations about the behaviour of isolated sticky-ended DNA fragments.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors wish to thank Dr R.Lavery (CNRS UPR 9080, Institut de Biologie Physico-chimique, Paris, France) for careful reading of the manuscript.
REFERENCES
This article has been cited by other articles:
This page is run by Oxford University Press, Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP, as part of the OUP Journals
Comments and feedback: www-admin{at}oup.co.uk
Last modification: 17 Apr 1998
Copyright©Oxford University Press, 1998.
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
L. Hamon, D. Pastre, P. Dupaigne, C. L. Breton, E. L. Cam, and O. Pietrement
High-resolution AFM imaging of single-stranded DNA-binding (SSB) protein--DNA complexes
Nucleic Acids Res.,
April 3, 2007;
35(8):
e58 - e58.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
D. Pastre, O. Pietrement, S. Fusil, F. Landousy, J. Jeusset, M.-O. David, L. Hamon, E. Le Cam, and A. Zozime
Adsorption of DNA to Mica Mediated by Divalent Counterions: A Theoretical and Experimental Study
Biophys. J.,
October 1, 2003;
85(4):
2507 - 2518.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
![]()
![]()
![]()

![]()
![]()
![]()
Z. Yingge, B. Chunli, W. Chen, and Z. Delu
Force Spectroscopy between Acetylcholine and Single Acetylcholinesterase Molecules and the Effects of Inhibitors and Reactivators Studied by Atomic Force Microscopy
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.,
April 12, 2001;
297(2):
798 - 803.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
![]()
This Article ![]()
![]()
Abstract
![]()
Print PDF (234K)
![]()
Alert me when this article is cited
![]()
Alert me if a correction is posted
![]()
Services ![]()
![]()
Email this article to a friend
![]()
Similar articles in this journal
![]()
Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
![]()
Similar articles in PubMed
![]()
Alert me to new issues of the journal
![]()
Add to My Personal Archive
![]()
Download to citation manager
![]()
Search for citing articles in:
ISI Web of Science (18)
![]()
Request Permissions ![]()
Commercial Re-use Guidelines
for Open Access NAR Content
![]()
Google Scholar ![]()
![]()
Articles by Revet, B.
![]()
Articles by Fourcade, A.
![]()
Search for Related Content
![]()
PubMed ![]()
![]()
PubMed Citation
![]()
Articles by Revet, B.
![]()
Articles by Fourcade, A.
![]()
Social Bookmarking ![]()
![]()
What's this?
